Where’s the Jubilee?
Since late fall global stock markets have managed to rally to multi-year highs despite global debt levels that continue to increase to all-time highs. Kondratieff theory holds that such excessive debt must be removed from corporate, individual and most of all sovereign balance sheets sooner or later. But since the global financial crisis began in earnest in 2007 central bankers have effectively delayed this process of debt retirement through the most ingenious and outrageous financial alchemy the world has ever seen. If you took a poll today, most would say these central bankers have averted a deflationary collapse that could have been seen as a full-blown Kondratieff Winter.
It is still possible to avert such a global deflationary meltdown but only if world leaders and central bankers could coordinate some form of a global jubilee on a grand scale. It’s by far the best solution to this dilemma that grows worse each day, each quarter, each year. Aggregate global debt obligations today exceed $100 trillion nominally and are so large they cannot be serviced by the output of those now so indebted and thus many countries are susceptible to the detriment of even marginally higher interest rates that could make repayment of their obligations impossible. An ideal example is Greece and Portugal, two countries that have virtually no exports that have been dependent upon government spending for a high portion of their GDP. They are the two countries most likely to default, and in fact Greece has already defaulted except as a technical matter.
Sadly, European leaders just don’t grasp super-cycle dynamics; for if they did they would know that imposing brutal austerity upon a people will not allow them to pay their debts. Surely, there must be some form of control imposed upon these distressed nations but not the type that will impede growth or their spirit of renewal. This must be encouraged, not discouraged as the austerity measures would do. Bondholders must take a bigger hit and take their medicine and learn a painful lesson themselves. But will they? That’s the big question and since the Greek bailout must be agreed to soon to avert the $19 billion coming due next month, world leaders and creditors better soon begin to embrace the jubilee concept or risk possible global contagion. The aggregate debt is just too big and we all know it.
Ironically, a settlement of the present Greek restructuring with a more robust haircut to the bondholders could sow the first seeds of the next spring cycle phase of the K-Wave. That is my hope, because no one wants to see the worst side of a Kondratieff Winter, not even those who are short the market. What is needed here is a coordinated jubilee among many classes of debt instruments (most notably sovereign debt of western nations including the US) that would give clarity and confidence going forward to all market participants- investors, entrepreneurs, workers, corporate management, and others so that the next growth phase of the cycle can begin in earnest with a firm foundation. Kondratieff theory holds that this is impossible without the removal of excessive debt. The sluggish growth seen in recent years that has occurred despite trillions in fiscal and monetary stimulus is the best evidence of all that more debt is not the answer.
The current market averages do not account for these excesses to be removed anytime soon. They assume central bankers will be able to pull the levers needed to prevent a recession or worse. Recently Chairman Bernanke asserted that the Fed would keep rates at near zero through 2014. I found this as surreal and it smacked to me of desperation considering that Bernanke’s term as Fed chief will end well before then. Has “Fed worship” become so acute that we actually believe such nonsense? In recent weeks a new euphoria has set in with the prospects of less worse unemployment and the looming IPO of Facebook. It’s great that some things are getting better but I wonder if anyone is giving serious consideration to this jubilee notion. I suspect however this matter will soon come to the fore and accordingly I have added some fresh material on this in the Jubilee section of our site. I encourage our readers to check this out and the works of David Knox Barker that can be seen at www.longwavedynamics.com. The jubilee concept called for in the book of Leviticus squares very nicely with the core theme of Kondratieff cycle, which has been around longer than we can imagine.
2011 Recap and a Primer for the Inflection Point of the K-Winter in 2012
“Check, please!”
The much anticipated Santa Claus rally in the days leading up to Christmas finally came and propelled the US averages to the same levels at this time last year. It seems like we have been running in place for years now and are now thoroughly exhausted. In fact, investors have little to show in the past year and much less over the past decade. There is a perfect explanation for this- the Kondratieff Winter that began in early 2000 and stocks historically perform awfully during this period.
The US averages are down around 15% on a nominal basis since 2000 and adjusted for inflation the major averages are down almost 40% since then and this pathetic performance has occurred with shockingly low volumes that belie any meaningful rallies of yesteryear. Efforts from Washington as well as the Federal Reserve that can be described as both unprecedented and truly gigantic in scope yet they have failed miserably to stem the deflationary tide. Debt levels among governments, corporations and individuals are now at all-time records by several standard deviations even after three plus years into this de-levering process brought about from the global financial crisis. In this year 2011, we saw new low water marks brought about by the K-Winter- the first ever downgrade of the US AAA credit rating, European sovereign debt being issued above the unsustainable 7% level, and a failed German bond auction among others. Have no illusions- we are now deep, deep into this fourth Kondratieff Winter of the modern industrialized era. So now what? I suspect it’s time for the “check, please”. The tab must be paid for much of the excesses of recent decades and the invoice has been sent.
As the saying goes, it’s time to pay the piper. It’s happening all over the world now with one notable exception- the US. It’s only because we hold the world’s reserve currency and have the most liquid market to be found anywhere in the world- the US Treasury market. Since our cost of capital remains low, we haven’t been forced into the austerity seen in Europe and other over-levered nations in the Western world but I suspect that condition will change in 2012. It’s really remarkable that the US stock market averages were flat for 2011 when you consider that China was down around 20% (and is now four years plus removed from their peak in 2007), Europe as a whole was down over 35% and essentially no country I can recall had a positive year in performance. Hence, US dollar hegemony impacts the US markets.
My outlook for 2012 for the markets is abundantly weak. I expect stocks to perform the worst, especially US stocks which have remained resilient to date and are thus more overpriced for this winter period. I expect bonds to rally and remain stable for a time but at some point I feel that the bubble in US Treasuries will soon burst, and when it does look out below. US Treasuries are the single most over-owned security in world history today and the risk-reward for them gets worse by the day. Although I have expected the worst period of the K-Winter to happen sooner, there are many reasons why I feel it’s closer than ever. So I will now review the various reasons supporting this and attempt to articulate the case to our readers.
When I launched this site in early October 2007 just days before the all-time nominal highs in the market averages, the content relied on the core of Kondratieff Wave theory and the insights provided by Robert Prechter, the world’s most esteemed practitioner of the Elliott Wave theory. As the crisis deepened in 2008 and into 2009 I was sure this was “the big one”. It felt right and the magnitude of the unfolding crisis was sufficiently awesome in scope. But in 2009, two things happened that altered my view in the short term. The first was the sheer scale and breadth of the bailouts coming from Washington and other was the financial alchemy coming from the Federal Reserve. I wasn’t sure either would get such a mandate but they did pull it off. It could have only happened if the US Congress and the American people suborned such grandiose efforts to stem the winter. They did, and by allowing such carte blanche they helped prevent a complete meltdown but perhaps unwittingly made things worse down the road. We now have several trillions more in debt today than March of 2009 yet we are no closer to meaningful improvements in economic growth and jobs or in rectifying the core problem of the Kondratieff Winter- trillions of excessive debt that is in jeopardy of default.
The second surprise to me was the EW Theorist report put out in late February 2009 by Robert Prechter. As a subscriber, I was expecting to see more confirmation at that time that the markets were set to go deeper in the abyss. But instead, his message was the complete opposite- cover all shorts and get long in a hurry. This rally he said would be longer and go farther than anyone could imagine and it sure did. It bottomed days later in early March and the subsequent rally actually went longer and farther than his own forecast. This can be directly attributable to, among other measures, Chairman Bernanke’s QE2 program that was announced in late summer of 2010 when it seemed the US economy was about to fall off a cliff. So in the spring of 2009 I took a step back and acknowledged it was perfectly acceptable within the parameters of K-Wave theory to allow for a very strong bear market rally in the interim.
However as someone so attuned to the Kondratieff Winter my natural inclinations were biased in believing the deflationary bust would occur sooner than later and in the spring of 2010 I was bearish (as was Prechter) and as it turned out we were both a bit early. But around this same time in the spring of 2010 I did discover another source of material that I found could be used to complement the K-Wave and Elliott Wave theories in projecting better when the real winter would take shape. It came in the form of the financial astrology of Ray Merriman at www.mmacycles.com. He provides daily and weekly analysis with paid subscriptions each Friday also provides a free update on his forecast for the coming week that is based on natal astrology. Eureka! This was the missing link I had been seeking all along and I began incorporating his findings into each blog I wrote each month. Meriman’s work makes it easy for us to understand the nature of financial astrology and its relevance to market cycle forces. Its relevance may surprise or perhaps stun even the most liberal and open-minded of us who seek alternative sources of knowledge in the capital markets. Today though, it could be seen as gem in the dark seeking the light of day because it never discussed by the mainstream financial press.
Here is a prime example of the manifestation of my evolution in becoming a true believer in this. In the spring of 2010 I expected that the so called bear rally from early March 2009 was long in the tooth and saw the US economy deteriorating so I was inclined to short the market. The “flash crash” in May of 2010 was the final kicker and convinced me we may be on the verge of a meltdown. But Ray Merriman had warned that a major astrological configuration was upcoming (Jupiter) and that this influence would be powerful and bring forth the animal spirits in the markets. Just as the markets appeared poised to capitulate in late August 2010 (foreshadowed by the so-called “death cross” in the charts) they reversed course and whipsawed higher once Bernanke announced QE2 in late August. To my chagrin, Merriman’s forecast was spot on and he rest is history- I was born again.
I was wrong to believe Bernanke lacked the will to enact such a blatant act befitting a Ponzi scheme but he did and the bottom line was that I misread the tea leaves in failing to see that the prevailing conditions coming from above would permit such a bold move at that time. Financial astrology serves to make sense of the maddening incoherence germane to the US stock market. Financial astrology to me seems a bit like a cheat sheet- simply ignore the headlines and just look for the conditions set for from the stars that influence human behavior. After the whipsaw following Jackson Hole in 2010 I realized the need to give this new source its due and I began to report Merriman’s themes and forecasts to my growing audience. I want more people to consider for themselves the relevance of this discipline and see for themselves how insightful it can be as a tool for guidance in the markets. We all know how truly maddening it can be trade the US market over the past few years and even the most seasoned and attuned money managers have been getting slaughtered. So I hope the concept of financial astrology gets more attention in the coming years as a credible tool for managing portfolios. Today it is the domain of a very tiny subset of traders and fund managers but I suspect it will grow measurably in acceptance over the coming years.
Lets’ recount another example of financial astrology in actions at its best. Recently in the summer of 2011 I was set to go “all-in” again shorting the market after the S&P downgrade over the summer. Just like the spring of 2010 it looked right to me. Merriman has warned too before that the Jupiter influence vanished in the spring of 2011 and the markets peaked then in late March. His forecast made it clear the markets would tank in the spring and summer of 2011 but get this- he warned over the summer in the midst of the biggest full-blown “risk off” period we had seen since the 2008-9 crisis- that good ol’ Jupiter was coming back as a major influence in November 2011 and this conjunction would last into early 2012. In the past, the events of late July and August would have validated my own convictions that this decline was “the big one”. But since I had learned before from this methodology of financial astrology that the influences from the heavens trump the headlines, I bit my tongue and held back and refrained from shorting the market and reflected this development in my monthly blog here. Sure enough, the markets plunged just over 20% into bear market territory and then shorts were taken to the woodshed yet again as the markets reversed higher just as the Jupiter influence returned. So note to self- don’t invade Vietnam and don’t short the market during any Jupiter conjunction. Merriman was right and for the first time in two years I didn’t get burned on the reversal higher. Merriman had proved to me that the answers for why this period was not destined to be the final capitulation were rooted to some degree in this strange but true discipline of natal financial astrology. When I researched the archive of weekly forecasts on his site going back to 2008 I was amazed at how well he had framed the juxtaposition of the markets in terms of what he calculated from the astrology above. And we are talking about some crucial periods here where he had to square the circle or if not anyone could dismiss this as heresy. Some may chuckle here at significance of financial astrology but I would just say to those to check out his forecasts for themselves. Their accuracy is just fantastic and almost a bit spooky. I just wish I had found him sooner because I could have saved myself a bit of aggravation.
So what is Merriman’s call for 2012? The end of Jupiter (rally) and the onset of increasing influence of two extremely significant astrological conjunctions. The first one is the influence of Pluto and Uranus and the next is the adjunct of Pluto in Capricorn. Pluto rules debt and removing from our world things that have proven to be oppressive to people. Capricorn represents all the impeding structures in our world that have been erected but do not serve the masses as they should. Institutions such as the IMF, the Fed and other central banks, the UN, etc would all fall into this group. Pluto in Capricorn actually began in 2007 with the Cardinal Cross alignment and lasts through 2015. Pluto also aligns with Uranus which represents upheaval, reversal, and unpredictability in general. Given that these are the primary influences from above for the next few years it is not a stretch to believe that the 2012-2015 period will be unlike any other we or our ancestors have ever seen in terms of radical and meaningful change all over the world.
So the bottom line of what I propose is this: all three of the disciplines I have studied and reported on here all suggest that the worst elements of the current Kondratieff Winter are set to unfold in the near term and the effects will be swift and possibly brutal. By their nature, two of these disciplines- the K-Wave and the Elliott Wave- are poor tools for near term market forecast because each cannot accurately predict in the short term the effects of human free will upon the larger model.
The K-Wave theory holds that the excesses built up over the present K-Wave cycle must be removed through large deflationary defaults but cannot forecast the exact timing of this event. Likewise, the Elliott Wave cannot always be used as a reliable indicator for the short term direction of the markets because the waves making up the primary count can be extended out through human decisions that can serve to delay the inevitable outcome. The best example of this is the QE2 program launched in the fall of 2010. In both of these the larger picture was very clear but the one in the near term not so much. But also there are true limits to the extent that the wave count in Elliott Wave theory can extend and likewise there are limits to how long the Kondratieff Winter can be forestalled because the weight of the excessive debt gets larger the longer it is extended. In any case, those who follow both of these generally expect the bottom to fall out pretty soon.
However, now for the first time the natal financial astrology promulgated by Ray Merriman suggests that the real inflection point for this economic winter is now very close at hand and he expects 2012 to be one of the worst years ever for the capital markets. What is worth noting here is the Merriman forecasts have resisted calling for a primary degree plunge since 2009 and thus his readers haven’t been exposed to the false alarms coming from EW and KW followers. Many of these have become disillusioned with Elliot Wave theory or the K-Wave theory because the US markets have to date stubbornly refused to cooperate. My take is this- the K-Wave has proven to be very accurate in reflecting the underlying conditions around the world for the past decade and to a lesser extent the Elliott Wave has been good in framing the big picture but since the Feb 2009 call has been poor in the short term. I believe once the market plunge begins in earnest both will be seen in a better light by their followers and doubters too.
What may kick off this inflection point in 2012 sending the markets much lower? The list is too long to recall here but I believe there are several critical factors that rise to the top of the list. These would include: credit ratings downgrades for many AAA rated European sovereign nations (most notably France), soaring bond yields in Italy, Spain and other major European sovereigns, protectionism and global trade wars, a spike in US long term interest rates as investors demand more yield for the risk, the perception of lasting political incompetence in the US and Europe in dealing with the K-Winter, a hard landing in China marked by an enormous property bubble and a growing sense of unease by investors and consumers who lose confidence in the economy and the capital markets. I will be watching the yields on long term Italian debt carefully because I suspect this is the market most likely to roil the global capital markets at some point in 2012. It fits with my belief that a rising yield deflationary collapse is on the horizon that may confound investors and pundits for years.
I relate our markets today to the period after the first sub-prime defaults occurred at Bear Stearns in the spring of 2007. The housing market had clearly peaked and anyone could see the makings of an enormous bubble yet the markets actually made all-time nominal highs later that year in October. Today, the bubble I see isn’t limited to one market- it’s the sum total of all the debt out there which many have estimated exceeds $120 trillion excluding several hundred trillion in outstanding derivatives. K-Wave theory holds that markets will not hold up in the face of such daunting levels. And now for the first time, the stars agree.
Note to our readers: On November 3rd I felt compelled to devote the entire monthly comments to introducing to our readers the works of one David Knox Barker, the author of www.longwavedynamics.com. This is one smart dude. Over the holidays I finished his latest book titled Jubilee on Wall Street and found it to be among the finest books I have ever read. In fact, I now regard him as the world’s top authority on long wave cycles and the Kondratieff Wave theory in particular. So next month I will be posting a comprehensive account here recounting his core themes and outlook for the remaining winter period and even more on the Kondratieff Spring period not far off. I urge our readers to strongly consider buying this book and please feel free to send us your comments. Barker has a technical mastery of the subject matter that far exceeds anything I’ve seen to date and his core theme on the K-Wave is unique in that it is parallel to the one we have advanced here- that we should be focusing more today on the next cycle phase- the Kondratieff Spring- and the wonders it will bring.
Ponzi Scheme in Peril: Bond Vigilantes up the Ante on Sovereign Debt
Look no further than the recent buyer’s strike of German bonds to see that this economic winter has entered a new stage. On Wednesday there were just no takers for nearly 40% of the bonds offered by the most creditworthy country in Europe so the Bundesbank had to step in to fill the gap and monetize their own debt. This bond auction was nothing less than a spectacular failure, the first I can ever recall in a major economy. The implications for this failure are daunting to say the least. Trillions of sovereign debt worldwide is coming due soon and must be rolled over but private investors have just sent us the first glimpse they just may pass. This may be the first chink in the armor of the global debt markets that now cannot take for granted that their future auctions will be fully subscribed unless higher rates are offered.
What has unfolded in the past few weeks strongly supports the case we have advanced here of a rising yield deflationary bubble. The prevailing thought has been that yields on all global debt would remain low in periods of low inflation and low growth such as the past few years. We have argued that we have been undergoing more deflation through a stealth form and that soon a tipping point would be reached when investors would demand much, much higher yields on toxic debt than the market was demanding then. Central Banks can declare low rates for however long they want but ultimately the market prevails in determining the level of rates. If nothing else, one thing is certain- interest rates are going higher for many years, like it or not.
Until recently the chase for yield had allowed investors to step out farther on the risk curve but now it’s like the song goes- “the times- they are a changing.”
In fact we just saw this month the first major victim in the chase for yield in the sudden bankruptcy of MF Global, a major commodities brokerage in Chicago run by former NJ governor John Corzine. His leveraged bet on high yield sovereign debt imploded almost overnight and the fallout is still reverberating throughout the markets. Many are comparing this event to the implosion of Bear Stearns in 2008 that preceded the market crash months later. Much like then it was taken on faith that the housing market would rise forever but certain assumptions that have worked for years just can’t be taken for granted anymore. The one now being questioned- that investors will settle for puny yields on government issued debt- is one we have questioned here for some time. When sentiment on such core themes reverse, the fallout can be swift and brutal.
In 2008 stock markets crashed when liquidity evaporated in the credit markets as it became clear that commercial and investment banks had insufficient capital to cover their risky bets on housing. Since then a great deal of toxic private debt has shifted to the public sector as US and foreign central banks and governments absorbed much of that toxic paper. And since they have dramatically increased their holdings of this toxic paper in the years since 2008 they now collectively hold tens of trillions of these assets. Yet until recently investors didn’t seem to care. It’s amazing to think that until just recently European sovereign debt traded in fantasy land but now this debt is beginning to be priced more in line with the bitter reality. Plain and simple, investors have mis-priced risk in these markets for some time now and it’s all coming come to roost. As we have said before- a ponzi scheme works perfectly until one day it doesn’t. That it did work for so long was no reflection on it’s sustainability.
At present stock markets all around the globe are in bear market territory save one- the US. Even China has under-performed for more than a year despite having unprecedented global reserves in the modern era. Sadly the prospect of global debt contagion is upon us again, occupying more copy in the press than even the most radical protest movements could ever muster. But such is the fate of the fait accompli of the Occupy Wall Street effort- a twisted tale long on passion but short on direction. Much the same could be said today for efforts to tame the massive global debt loads we have been blowing our horn about for so long that are the mother’s milk of any Kondratieff Winter.
Want more signs that the 60 year super-cycle in credit is close to implosion? Look no further than the blow-out spreads on the credit default swaps of sovereign Euro debt such as Spain, Italy and now even France too. Amazingly, US sovereign debt markets have coasted throughout the Euro crisis because we are still considered the best safe harbor in the world to park capital in times of crisis. This is still the case in part due to our role as the undisputed global leader in capital formation and profits but it can also be attributed in large part to the enormous benefit we still enjoy as the country with the lowest cost of capital in the world by a mile. This endures however only so long as US dollar hegemony remains the law of the land, i.e. the USD as the global reserve currency.
This hegemony is now under more pressure than ever as emerging giants such as China and others have gained new thresholds in the form of foreign currency capital reserves that are today the highest in recorded history among major powers outside the US. Nonetheless, I believe the USD will remain the reserve currency by default for many years until a new global standard is implemented. Until then, the US is likely to retain the benefits of of a low cost of capital relative to other nations but we are still not immune to higher rates too. I expect in 2012 we will see ever higher rates paid for US Treasury debt when investors begin to demand to be paid more for the risk of owning our bonds. Our national debt last week eclipsed $15 trillion and our debt to GDP is approaching 100%, a level seen as problematic to investors.
Given the severe problems in Europe, the US is also likely to suffer more than most from the global economic contraction brought about by the excessive debt loads throughout the world. Our export markets are suffering and our global giants who depend so much on global growth will also suffer. Looking back years from now 2011 S&P profits approaching the $100 level may prove to be a peak level for the cycle because of the limitations inherent with record global debt. Austerity will be a core theme for several years as nations, corporations and individuals continue to de-lever. It will become all too clear soon that so much of our perceived prosperity came through debt induced growth at the margin that could not be sustained. The hallmark trait of the winter phase of the Kondratieff Cycle is marked by this process of removing the excesses and mal-investment that have endured for so long.
What can we do now to mitigate the worst effects of this painful process? Above all I think is to get a renewed sense of cooperation among our elected officials in Washington. At stake here is nothing less than the full faith and confidence of our capital markets, most notably our Treasury market. We need a grand bargain now more than we know because without a road map directing several trillions in spending cuts for the next 4-6 years we risk undermining our own prosperity in the form of higher interest rates that will gobble up a much higher percentage of our Treasury receipts. Because the vast majority of the US national debt is short term this condition could easily morph into a vicious cycle that can perpetuate itself if it reaches a critical mass.
Each day the status quo remains the same we approach a point where reversing the trend will become too difficult. We can give thanks now that the US is a flight to safety for so much foreign capital but we cant take this for granted. I hope we see a renewed fight in Congress to begin anew the process abandoned by the so-called Super-Committee that was an abject failure. I hold out hope that a group of strong-willed junior representatives can muster support for a Grand Bargain to get us going again. With a vacuum of leadership all throughout the world the stage is set for those who have the conviction to make a difference, and the sooner the better.
The Perfect Storm in a Kondratieff Long Wave Winter
This comes to us from our friends at one of my favorites sites for progressive financial reporting- www.seekingalpha.com. It was written by David Knox Barker of www.longwavedynamics.com, another great source for Kondratieff Wave analysis. The core theme of this piece squares nicely with the material advanced on here on our site and provides a reasonable snapshot of the present conditions in the capital markets against the framework of the larger economic cycles.
Of particular interest to me is the chart shown on the final page. It shows the trajectory of interest rates in the US from the beginning of the current fourth Kondratieff cycle (1949-2015) as we have advanced throughout the material here.
The image of this chart on rates is hard to ignore- a near perfect pyramid showing rates rising from the bottom at the beginning of the KW cycle as defined by the K-Wave theory in the early 1950’s and peaking thirty years later in the early 1980’s and then sinking to near zero at the end of the cycle in recent years.
The symmetry within the pyramid chart of interest rates is striking. Notice that that the peak in rates occurs precisely at the half-way point (1981-82) of the K-Wave cycle. This coincides with the period when hard assets (gold, oil, etc) peaked and ushered in the era of outsized gains (understatement) for paper assets from 1981-82 until recent years. It is clear even at first glance of this pyramid chart that a major transformation occurred in this crucial period in the early 1980’s and it coincides with the transformation to the 3rd stage of the K-Wave cycle- summer. We have already established in our content here that the summer season of the K-Wave began during this period of the early 1980’s but we had lacked a chart directly linking interest rates to the K-Wave cycle. This chart reveals a crucial missing link supporting the seasonal theme of the K-Wave theory that is confirmed through interest rates as seen in their natural cycles.
These economic seasons are naturally recurring patterns endowed with nature’s harmonic ratios that are a part of the natural order before us and to that end I have recently added some material in our Esoteric section from Rick Santelli at CNBC that supports this further through sacred geometry. I encourage our readers to read this and examine these charts and make your own conclusions. They suggest to me one core theme- interest rates are at or near lows for a long, long time. Moreover, the implications from this pyramid chart strongly reinforces the idea I have advanced in recent months- a rising yield deflationary collapse of paper assets that may baffle the experts.
Never mind the prevailing presumption today that rates will be kept low so long as the Fed can help it. We beg to differ. The charts beg to differ. Remember that “Operation Twist” from the Fed has floundered in lowering long term interest rates because global central banks and the primary dealers of the US Treasury are all too willing to sell their toxic paper back to the mother of all suckers- the Federal Reserve. Remember the Fed dumped gold under $300 for a decade and begin buying it back over $1000 when they finally realize they’ve lost control of a once tight market. Now they are buying the most toxic assets on Earth- long term US debt sure to be devalued if not first defaulted.
Just look at the recent data being reported from the US Treasury. The reality is inescapable here- the foreign component at these Treasury debt auctions has been waning for months and they are now net sellers of US debt. That is to me a megatrend game-changer that may not baked into the current all-time low yields.
In the near term we may continue to see yields on US government debt creep lower when fears mount over systemic risk in the European banking system, but I suspect at some point soon yields will reverse higher in the US in paradox when investors realize that bonds are also paper assets that are prone to lose value during a Kondratieff Winter.
Must Read! The Perfect Storm In A Kondratieff Long Wave Winter
European Showdown Looms Large
It’s all come down to this- either the Eurozone leaders will soon go “all-in” to help Greece, Dexia, Spain and Italy or they won’t. A key vote is upcoming that could establish a special purpose vehicle (EFSF) to recapitalize Europe’s weakest banks. It appears now it will pass after and they are likely to triple down on more commitments in hopes of preventing the contagion from exploding further. Never mind the riots in Greece or the growing unrest of working Germans who are footing the bill. The will of the people in Europe remains subjugated to the elites and the bankers for now but I expect that to change in 2012. So how would a European TARP style bailout of their banking system figure in our looming Kondratieff Winter?
I suspect it could push out the final act into the early months of 2012 but not much farther. Let’s face it- the central banks of the western world are tapped out and looking more impotent each day. Several years of fancy and risky maneuvers (QE2, Operation Twist,TARP, EFSF, QE1, etc) have been promulgated yet they still have not increased global growth sufficiently. Instead these programs have left us with trillions more in debt obligations that must be reconciled. I look for the brunt of this to occur in 2012 and beyond.
But nonetheless today the US is technically not in a recession and earnings are still relatively strong, so there’s no reason to believe the bulls can’t make one last charge higher into 2012. The fourth quarter has historically been one of the strongest periods for stock gains even during this present Kondratieff Winter. After testing support twice at 1070 on the S&P it appears that support has held and I think we could see a multi-week advance in stocks so long as there is no formal default in Europe.
The primary counts from the Elliott Wave model and the financial astrology of Ray Merriman (mmacycles.com) also support this forecast. EW charts I’ve seen reflect a ending diagonal pattern that would suggest higher prices ahead for stocks given the resilience of the past week in the face of near doomsday mindset of investors. Likewise Merriman’s financial astrology indicates the looming influence of Jupiter across our heavens beginning soon will provide the ideal backdrop for excess speculation in the markets to take the averages higher. Once again much like the period of June 2009-March 2011 where Jupiter’s influence was cresting and clearly caused significant undue speculation that did impact our markets to the upside.
Don’t laugh folks, this stuff in all too real. But let’s also remember that the primary count for Merriman, the EW, and with our K-Wave theory that still holds that 2012-1015 will be quite brutal for the capital markets. In EW terms, the P3 (Primary Wave 3) down is the big one and it’s been brewing now for some time. In financial astrology terms, the period from 2012-2015 represents the tail end of the Cardinal Climax, the most significant geo-cosmic signature ever seen on the modern western world whose primary feature is a conjunction of Pluto in Capricorn representing the destruction of anything constructed in the material world that’s not good most humans and chief among these is debt.
Yet still the hallmarks of a Kondratieff Winter continue to play out before us each day. China now seems vulnerable to a hard landing, a fate that would have severe implications for global growth even in the absence of any trade wars over currency manipulation. Home prices and consumer sentiment continue to plunge and the Occupy Wall Street protests seen in recent days and weeks make you think we are back in the 1960’s again. But this exploding civil protest is a natural feature of any Kondratieff Winter and it stands to reason we will see more of these everywhere. Social unrest also plays a primary part in the forecast of Elliott Wave theory which holds that capital markets are more influenced by waves of social mood than profits. It’s been hard for stock markets to sustain their gains for too long when the balance of wealth within its population becomes so distorted and outlook of the people is as unsure as it is today. History has shown this precept to be accurate to a primary degree yet few take heed of such non-material inputs in their market forecasting models. I do.
Now back to the tempest in the teapot- the European financial crisis now in its fourth year and literally on the brink as its banking system is on the verge of collapse. The solution now being advanced is to create a special purpose vehicle to recapitalize European banks with 8 to 1 leverage to be sufficiently large to prevent a run on the banks. This plan smacks of insanity but is par for the course now with sovereign debt in the modern age. However its what the markets have been demanding so naturally they just may get what they want- for now.
Whatever, I believe very strongly the citizens of Europe are poorly served by these new accords that continue to pile on more debt. Under this approach the creditors are demanding austere measures sure to cripple the economies of the debtor nations. Yet history has shown us many times that if a single country (Brazil, Argentenia, etc) can devalue their currency they can export their goods more competitively and come back stronger than ever. Who would have thought for example as recently as 2000 that Brazil would emerge as one of the strongest nations in the world after such a checkered history of defaults and devaluations of their currency? Currency devaluation can help so long as every nation on Earth doesn’t do it all at once.
Last month even Switzerland, the final bastion of hard currency (other than Norway) finally relented and devalued their own Swiss Franc due to the effects of over appreciation of their currency had upon their own economy. Such a move was unprecedented and soon caused a scandal at UBS when a rogue trader bet too heavily on the omniscient trajectory of the Swiss France. And much like the US housing market a few years earlier it proved to be awful to bet on a market going up forever. Yet those bets were still placed anyway.
It is all too clear that subsidizing private profits at the expense of socialized loss (taxpayers) needs to be abolished in every form in every country by everyone. Yet under this approach one party does indeed lose- the speculative bankers that lent the money. They have been protected all along by the leaders ever since the global financial crisis began in 2007 yet we are now seeing the first signs that the ice is beginning to finally crack under their feet. So look for the haircuts to the European banks in the looming Euro settlement to approach 50% instead of the 20% agreed by all parties three months ago in mid-July. The world has changed too much since then and the piper must be paid.
But how? I would advance this- debt repatriation on a massive global scale never seen before through an ever- expansive series of debt forgiveness accords that are needed to complete the last phase, the winter, of this Kondratieff Wave cycle. The debt jubilee that is such a good thing is already upon us even though we can’t even see it yet. For example, the bondholder for Jefferson County in Alabama were forced recently to take a haircut of over $1 billion to prevent that municipality form going bankrupt (It still may). That we can expect to see a great deal more of debt forgiveness it the future may be a titanic understatement. Folks, the jubilee process of this Kondratieff Winter has already begun.
I hope the sooner that global leaders can coordinate this global settlement the sooner we can expect to reap the rewards promised by the gains we’ve seen in technology and productivity made the past several years. That is our future and I just hope it comes sooner than later. The Kondratieff Spring is just around the corner.
Aug 17, 2011 Special Report: The Twilight of Paper Assets
Deconstructing the timeline of this Kondratieff Winter
Given the recent market turmoil I can’t imagine a better time than now to provide to our readers some guidance on how to assess where we are in the grand scheme of this Kondratieff Winter. Since the global financial meltdown began in 2008 it has been difficult to ascertain how far along this winter cycle phase had evolved because of the degree of interference that has taken place in the form of monetary and fiscal stimulus that has been unprecedented in it’s scope or breadth. The first wave that included TARP, the AIG and automotive bailouts, the homebuyer tax credits and cash for clunkers,etc. only helped the economy in the very short term as did Bernanke’s QE2 announced one year ago. However a clear pattern has been established – when these temporary measures expired the economy relapsed to a point worse off than before these programs were initiated. Such is the curse of an ignorant approach to fighting a Kondratieff Winter.
Kondratieff Wave theory strongly suggests that fighting an economic winter brought about through excessive credit with more credit is futile. I believe recent history confirms this despite Bernanke’s stubborn resolve to double down on further monetary stimulus when economic date reveals weakness. He firmly believes the critical mistake the Fed made in the 19030’s was being too timid in providing extraordinary monetary stimulus. His speech in 2002 that invoked Milton Friedman’s helicopter drop of money wasn’t to be taken literally. Yet his real intention was- to do everything under the sun and more to fight delation through any means necessary. Such a reckless approach sadly fails to recognize the limitations of Fed policy during the tail ends of credit super-cycles such as the present nor does it account for the potential for the serious unintended consequences of such a draconian approach. And most of all it does not square with Kondratieff theory that mandates that any efforts to increase debt during these periods compound the entire situation. So on the eve of his crucial speech next Friday at Jackson Hole, Wyoming I seek to parse the present stage of this economic winter to better frame the economic and capital market backdrop underlying the present stage of the cycle.
The fledging European union is now in the late stages of a terminal debt cancer that is forcing hard decisions to be made by their leaders. The “kicking the can down the road” era is in it’s twilight, and the doubling down by the ECB and Germany is looking more each day like a fool’s errand. Here in the US it’s better but not by much. This is clear- the jury is out and most of us believe crucial mistakes have been made by our leaders. I find it really sad that President Obama rejected the Simpson-Bowles plan released last December. It was tough and called for the sacred cows of each party to be shot down, but no one listened and no one cared and we are worse today for such a disgraceful exhibition. Now that the perils of excessive debt are front page news each day let’s discus where we stand in the late stages of this economic winter unfolding before us each day.
Why? Because it matters, and more than we can appreciate. Always has, but especially now. Where are we in this fourth Kondratieff Winter of the modern age?How exactly does it intersect with other larger forces (sovereign defaults, for example) now coming into the fold? Purists of K-Wave theory may be excited because the threat of debt bombs soon exploding is sure to dominate the news for some time to come. But this condition is awful and nothing to revel in, and thus the primary focus for those who understand these themes should be centered on using the universal principles of long eave cycle dynamics to help us manage our own economies better. If this K-Winter comes about as I suspect I doubt many will celebrate.
Turning things around would be made more possible if our leaders better understood the nature of the natural cycles of economic growth in modern industrialized nations. Fortunately Nikolai Kondratieff greatly enhanced our ability to make this connection. The core themes set forth on this site come from our comrade, one Nikolai Kondratieff. In 1925 he wrote the magnum opus on long wave super-cycle economics- Long Waves in Economic Life. It was a brilliant treatise that was original in it’s presumptive theme that all markets are governed indirectly from forces not so well known even today. Sadly this is still true.
Comrade Kondratieff knew better even as early as 1925, decades before the digital revolution, that long-wave cycle theory was just too relevant to ignore.
That’s worth saying twice. These long wave cycles matter, and we should take heed.These patterns of economic boom and bust have been a hallmark of the human socio-economic framework for so many eons and Kondratieff managed to develop a template of distinctive economic growth patterns that endures today. So lets now examine more closely why these themes are likely to still endure and why they matter now.
Framing the Backdrop
The prevailing theme of any Kondratieff Winter is that large amounts of debt can’t be sustained over time. This notion may seem trite but it’s quite compelling.Some would argue that the Kondratieff Winter peaked in 2008, and I wish I could agree with them. Here, I honestly hope I am wrong. But if this is the case then it would render K-Wave cycle theory far less meaningful as a tool for economic analysis in the future. Why? Because under K-Wave theory the economic winter doesn’t shift into a new super-cycle (60 years or so) until a large amount of the excesses of the previous cycle have been mitigated. It hasn’t, not by a long shot.
Now a quick primer on the dates that set up this fourth K-WInter of the modern era. This fourth cycle of the modern industrialized era began approximately in 1949 as the US began evolving from a wartime economy to one with high growth centered on the suburban boom and the onset of mass consumerism. Each of the four seasons in modern K-Wave cycles average approximately 15 years. The summer phase began in 1983 at the onset of the greatest bull market in world history. It ended in January 2000 when the market averages all peaked in real terms. Although the S&P and the Dow made nominal highs in 2007, these levels were far below the peak 2000 levels in real terms when adjusted for inflation. The NASDAQ topped out over 5000 in 2000 and only regained just a bit more than half at the 2007 highs and it’s now down over 80% today from its highs in 2000 when adjusted for inflation. So since it’s a fact that the highs in the market averages in real terms were posted over 11 years ago it’s hardly a stretch to argue that we have been in a Kondratieff Winter since then.
In previous K-Wave cycles, the pattern repeats. The summer is always has the biggest gains for stocks and the winter is the worst. That makes sense to me as those two seasons are the extremes. But when you compare the present period to the late 1940’s, you begin to doubt we are beginning a new spring cycle of growth. In the late 1940‘s the US had dramatically reduced it’s debt and was growing at an incredible pace. And let’s remember that much of the debt that had accrued was an outlier due to WW2, unlike the present debt load which is the result of several decades of outliving our means.
The present economic winter began in 2000 and it’s worst effects have been put off through unprecedented stimulus from the US Treasury and the Fed. But I hope our readers have figured out the good news by now- we are already 11 years into this winter, yes? That’s right, and that’s good news. But the flip-side is that the worst part of the winter may be upon us soon and during this relatively brief period a staggering amount of excesses must be rid from the system so we can begin a new cycle of growth on a firmer foundation. I expect that period to be 2013-2015 under the Kondratieff Wave theory. I feel the most damage to the capital markets and the economy will be from 2012-2013 as the accrued tensions of tens of trillions of debt that have been accumulated come to bear upon the markets. This will cause a great number of extremely large defaults that must be written off and only then can a new foundation for the spring cycle phase begin.
The approach from the Fed in the 1930’s in response to the Great Depression was far more muted than today and as a result it lasted far longer than most could have imagined. But monetary policy alone cannot reverse decades of excesses that have accrued so under K-Wave theory the Great Depression would happened anyway. Fed policy today in response to the global financial crisis was the exact opposite and has been executed almost precisely as Bernanke asserted in his famous speech in 2002 that earned him the moniker “Helicopter Ben”. But if you subscribe to the K-Wave theory, then you realize what this means- by doubling and tripling down at each turn, Bernanke’s approach assures a much swifter but far more brutal end game. As anyone can see literally and intuitively, Fed policy over the past thirty years has spawned one bubble after another (internet- 2000, housing 2007, oil and nat gas 2008, etc.) One could easily argue the combination of near permanent ZIRP (zero int rate policy) and QE 1,2 etc have set the stage for the grandest bubble of all to burst- the US govt securities market, along with other sovereign debt markets.
Bernanke is still convinced Fed policy can defeat deflation and the man no doubt knows about the K-Wave, yet he still feels his alchemy can defeat the deflationary bubble at the heart of this Kondratieff Winter. The question of our time is this- can Bernanke beat a deflationary winter that’s right on schedule? I believe he can’t because Fed policy in the modern era fails to acknowledge that loose monetary policy can’t stimulate growth at the margins. Evidence for this theme is abundant. Most notably, we have seen home prices steadily erode for six years despite mortgage rates at near record lows. I suspect one day the post-mortem from the modern Fed will center on this- you just can’t push on a string with low rates.
What other signs indicate an economic winter is already upon us? For starters, the moving averages of all the major indexes in the US and in many other major equity markets have been breached to the downside by a primary degree. And the absurdity of the staggering levels of global debt that have been attained are just awesome. We have been living large for too long with debt levels in local, state, federal, private, and corporate terms now at all-time highs and still beaming higher. Yet so few people today are aware of the nature or implications of long term economic wave theory. Thus, the Kondratieff WInter marches on in full display to the folly of those too ignorant to know the traits of an economic winter. There is some discourse and there are many headlines on the the significance of global debt levels, yet the mainstream financial press and nearly all our economic and political leaders still have yet to square the circle of the criticality of super cycle dynamics as they relate to modern global economies.
Another indication that we are now in the final throes of an economic winter can be seen through the sacred geometry found today in stock and bond charts.
First, let’s get to US Treasury bonds. Of particular interest is a key date that just happens to be today-August 22, 2011. That’s the 34 year anniversary since the thirty year bond began trading on the Chicago BOT. For a better perspective on the significance of this I have recently added to the sacred geometry tab a two page blog from Rick Santelli of CNBC who myself and many others consider to be a leading expert on the Treasury market. In his blog Santelli suggests a top may be soon at hand in US Treasuries due to the Fibonacci 34 year interval deemed to be very significant under the sacred geometry principles advanced by W. D. Gann, the legendary technician of the capital markets not so well known to most. More on this can be found in the Sacred Geometry tab in the Esoteric Section.
We can also also look to Kondratieff’s Wave theory to find a top forming in US bonds. If you remember, interest rates peaked in 1982 just as the summer phase cycle of the fourth Kondratieff Wave was beginning. Stocks and bonds both bottomed within a period of time that could be seen as minute in super-cycle terms. I would argue that stocks have performed very much in line with the K-Wave cycle but would also admit US Treasuries have not. In fact, US bonds, ceterus paribas, (holding all things constant) have since the beginning of the Kondratieff Winter in 2000 have dramatically outperformed equities and the reason is quite obvious- the Fed has maintained interest rates lower for longer during this period than at any other period of time in US history.
Moreover, the Fed has compounded this by resorting to the same desperate policy measures taken by Japan for decades- quantitative easing- to the tune of several trillions of dollars, thus skewing the Kondratieff Winter for bonds to a primary degree. To that end I will say this- the potential for losses for bonds during this winter is much larger than for stocks. Why? Because the stock prices of many cash rich corporate giants such as IBM, Apple, McDonalds, etc. will survive and perhaps even thrive during this winter. But most government bonds are fraught with much more inherent risk than now perceived by investors and could plunge far from their all-time highs now, especially if W.D. Gann’s math is right. If last Thursday’s auction of 30 year Treasury bonds is any indication, Gann is right on. Santelli gave the auction a grade of F for the first time ever.
Linking the K-Wave and Elliott Wave
The primary count today in the Elliott Wave also indicates the homestretch of the Kondratieff Winter has already begun. For several years, these charts have projected that a final wave down- the dreaded P3 Wave down- would finally come to mark the end of this economic super-cycle. The first wave down occurred from late 2007 until March 2009 and the P2 countertrend wave since then has baffled most bears because it extended farther and for longer than most of us thought possible. This P2 wave is essentially a bear market rally that was extended much farther as a direct result of the previously unfathomable policy measures taken primarily by the Federal Reserve and to a lesser extent the US Treasury.
It must me noted that the P2 countertrend rally from March 2009 until April 2011 satisfied Elliot Wave principles in that the high of 1370 in the S&P made in April fell well short of the October 2007 high of 1543. Thus the methodology underlying the P3 Wave down was intact all along yet there was one final element missing for the P3 wave to begin in earnest- a degradation of social mood. That finally occurred in late July courtesy of the Congressional debt ceiling fiasco that became the proverbial straw that broke the camel’s back. Fittingly the market decline in late July correlated precisely with this radical shift in public mood of hopelessness that Washington could provide any solutions to this mess.
The most recent Elliott Wave Theorist dovetailed very nicely with an abundance of distinct themes from Kondratiieff theory I have advanced here. FIrst is that the bulk of the damage coming in this winter will come during the final homestretch and the EWT projects that the bulk of the market losses will occur between now and the end of 2012 and extending through 2015. Prechter goes on to compare the present period to the 1937 period when the market began it’s worst stretch by losing over 83% in a very short period, a period Prechter incidentally regards as the last time we were in a Kondratieff Winter.
The EWT also examined exactly how this stealth economic winter was able to take place under our noses for over a decade. In fact most have been oblivious to it because the monetary debasement done by the Fed has made it not seem so bad to us but that’s only because we have been deluded by the nominal gains and haven’t adjusted for price gains in real terms. Upon the further scrutiny of measuring the gains since 2000 Prechter chose to measure these vs. a Stable Currency Benchmark (a blend of hard currencies and gold) and these charts show those gains were illusory. Much like Michael Douglas said in the original Wall Street film-the illusion had become real.
Finally, the EW model overlays neatly with the end of the Kondratieff Cycle as occurring in 2015-16 as I have advanced here for years. The model suggests not only that this period will see an astonishing level of wealth destroyed in a short time, but more importantly that a multi-decade long term bottom will also be in place. If that occurs, the Kondratieff Wave will have played out much in line with its projected 15 year duration (2000-2015) as one of the four 15 year seasons in a 60 year economic super-cycle. And I suspect that would also shock those few sufficiently educated about the notion of economic super-cycles but were long convinced in it’s apparent holes. Again here, the illusion has become real.
The EWT also revisited many of the themes that have been put forth for years. Most prominent among them is that social mood, not corporate earnings, is the primary driver of the capital markets. With that in mind, just seeing what is happening around the globe makes me very wary that the capital markets will perform under the guidelines of the metrics that have shaped price behavior for the past several decades. I see a day soon where PE multiples will mean squat and Keynesian model for measuring economic performance will be thrown out the window. Western economies are imploding under the weight of global sovereign debt and may soon reach a point of no return when the austerity demanded to repay the mighty sovereign debt precluded that very debt from being repaid. It seems to be that we are now in the early ninth inning on the present economic winter with only one saving grace- a well coordinated program of jubilee for the massive defaults looming. But sadly I just don’t see the action on the ground to support this and neither do the charts. That said, it’s likely we are now in the twilight of the reign of paper assets that began in the early 1980’s.
I would like to also provide here some input from others for discussion that’s relevant the Kondratieff Wave. Noted cycle technician Martin Armstrong has developed an economic confidence model that calls for the present period to serve as a bottom in confidence that will precede several years of growth before a multi-century bottom that would occur in the last 2020’s with a new grand super-cycle beginning in late 2032. Armstrong’s work is based upon a long wave cycle of 309 years plus and I have found his work to be extremely fascinating and very credible. I have recently added his most recent major piece in the K-Wave section of this site. I happen to disagree with him that the current cycle could be stretched that much further but who knows?
According to Biblical scholar Daniel Gregg the next Biblical jubilee is due to happen around this period in 2036. I have included on our site material from Gregg on this in the Jubilee section under the KW Spring tab. In the second piece titled “Will the Kondratieff Cycle Revert to the Jubilee Average?” Gregg takes aim at the historical overlay to these long cycles with the dates of each jubilee ever recorded since the days of the Hebrews. According to Gregg, the last one was in 1987 but did not take hold with wholesale debt forgiveness and thus the cycle was extended further out to 2007. One could argue that we are still in the jubilee period now and are on the verge of massive global defaults that will usher in the mother of all jubilees. In this piece Gregg also reasons that the Kondratieff Wave has been extended in duration due to technology and the scale of monetary stimulus that has taken effect. I agree with him on this and I believe this accounts for the increase in the economic long wave cycle over the eons from 51.6 years in earlier times to around 60 years now. Long Wave cycles need not be as overly precise as detractors would demand but instead sufficient to overcome scrutiny considered to be reasonable. After all human will does influence any outcome.
Conclusion
So what’s the bottom line for investors? I would advance this- we are now in the late innings of the final cycle phase of the Kondratieff Cycle- the winter- but unlike the Great Depression we will endure a briefer but harsher economic winter and also that the difficult homestretch period has only just begun. Some of It’s worst effects can still be mitigated however if US and global leaders can come together and coordinate an effective jubilee that will serve to extinguish the bulk of non-performing debt so detrimental to global prosperity. We must come to see the Kondratieff Winter for what it really is- a wrecking ball that need only be used when we allow our own excesses to control our destiny. That is the case now as global debt levels are trumping everything in sight. To that end, i conclude with this from Daniel Gregg in his Jubilee piece on our site:
“The Jubilee is the Bible’s preventative measure against depression. If it were observed, then it would preempt the depressions and prevent them. But when the Jubilee isn’t observed, the natural economic cycle charted by Nikolai Kondratieff takes over.” Let’s hope our leaders soon discover this wisdom.
The Case for a Rising Yield Winter
In just the past week, perception has finally caught up with the reality we have been discussing here for several years.
Suddenly, debt levels do matter. They do trump corporate earnings and just about anything else for that matter. The complacency we alluded to last month has given way to full-blown fear. But this time is much different than 2008 when the markets plunged because the solvency of a few key institutions (AIG, Lehman, Fanny Mae, Citibank). They collapsed then through the perception of counter-party-risk brought about by excessive leverage that was rampant for years throughout the financial system.
Today we are nearly three years into a massive de-leveraging process that is still far from removing the greater part of the excesses that have been built up for so long. Structural impediments to growth still abound with unemployment, housing and consumer confidence still ailing. The ugly mess in Washington with the struggle to raise the debt ceiling and the recent historic downgrade of US government debt by S&P dealt a strong blow to our own collective self- esteem that spilled over into the markets. And fittingly, selling volume has been far higher than the weak volume associated with the rallies over the past year.
Last week the major averages plunged over 7% and there’s a growing sense among investors and the public at large that things are spinning out of control. Years from now we may look back to this week as a paradigm shift in the collective consciousness to a new reality we have been loathe to confront- that we have ignored the true significance of global debt levels.The markets though are taking notice. Such an about face was characterized best by the greeting investors gave at the opening bell Monday after it became clear over the weekend that the debt ceiling would be raised. The opening gap up over 140 points was rudely dismissed in a matter of seconds and it was all downhill from there. Panic selling was evident throughout the week yet not capitulation, and that is a bit scary. We may be oversold a bit in the short term and the averages are quite capable of staging a modest rally soon but my sense is that the 1379 April highs on the S&P index won’t be eclipsed for a long, long time. Significant technical damage has been done that essentially broke the uptrend that had been in place since the spring of 2009. There’s no doubt that the preponderance of high frequency trading in the markets have accelerated this plunge and thus the move downward the past two weeks has been even swifter than in 2008.
It appears two distinct themes are in play now. One is the unfolding contagion in Europe that escalated to its highest level yet last week courtesy of the looming bailout of Italy, one of the largest economies in Europe. Investors are finally taking hold of the notion that a full blown crisis in Euro zone, the largest economy in the world, may impact global growth after all. Remarkably, until just days ago no one seemed to think it would.
The other and perhaps more damning though was the impression that the US and European political and economic leadership are clueless to deal with the tragedy unfolding before us each day. It’s clear to most that a perfect storm of self-serving interests and shocking ineptitude by our President, the Congress, the ECB, etc. has sapped the single most important element needed for the capital markets to function properly- confidence.
The stunning plunge in confidence seen lately is very frightening to me but well placed unfortunately. It is compounded by the attrition brought on through decades of excessive credit and mal investment. Sovereign nations are now crumbling under the very weight of the credit markets that have been propped them up for far too long. Suddenly the capital markets have sensed this and have sold off sharply- except one- US Treasuries, the largest capital market anywhere. Here’s why I think a long term top is this overcrowded market is close at hand.
US Treasuries were just last Thursday at or near all-time highs at every maturity. SInce the global economic crisis began in 2007 we’ve seen the same pattern trace out- dollar down, stocks up and bonds flat to down during risk-on periods and vice-versa during risk off periods. However I believe this pattern is about to reverse soon if so it could shake the capital markets to their core. The bottom line? In the coming days or weeks, a liquidity crunch will take place the likes of which we have never seen before in our lifetimes and you can throw out all the past rules of thumb. Dollar up, stocks down. Risk-off, bonds down. In fact in such a period (i.e. the endgame of a K-Winter) the mantra is very simple- all paper assets including stocks, bonds, commodities, and even gold are down. Cash is king, not gold. And the rush to raise cash may have only just begun. Even US Treasuries are susceptible to liquidation.
Here’s how it could play out. As stocks plunge and margin calls mandate more selling stocks continue to sell off. Nothing new here, this has happened before (1929, 1987, 2008, etc). Even sacred cows such as gold get sold off hard such as in 2008 when gold plunged from $941 to $722 from August to September. Investors sell their winners to raise cash and meet margin calls. So this wouldn’t be too big a surprise. But a massive sell-off in US Treasuries across the curve would be a shock. It’s the one thing investors haven’t priced in one bit but it’s quite possible. I hope it doesn’t occur but I believe it will.
The scenario I am describing was put forth in recent months by the guys at my favorite site for daily Elliott Wave counts www.danericselliotwaveblogspots.com. I have come to admire their insight for a multitude for reasons chief among them their inclination to be humbled when they get the count wrong. I have alerted our readers in recent monthly blogs to the radical and quite unusual theory they have put forth regarding what will precipitate this final stage of the fourth Kondratieff Winter of the modern era. They call it a rising yield deflationary collapse, a theory that’s never made its way into collegiate
textbooks or event he modern lexicon because it’s never happened. But is sure makes sense to me. I always felt there would be a wrinkle that few had ever considered that would prove to be the defining element of the P3 wave down in the capital markets. This is no ordinary deflationary collapse and I wouldn’t expect it to look like any other. A rising yield collapse that would baffle most academics and experts makes just too much sense to me to ignore.
Here’s how a rising yield winter could play out: Initially the yield curve flattens as fools rush in as the entire hedge fund universe flocks to Treasuries. The long bond gains the most in the first inning as the greed for high yield trumps any wisdom hedge fund managers learned years ago. The long bond should lead the surge down in yields and when the music stops I feel it will lead it higher, dragging yields across the curve higher and ripping the faces off of those who dared to believe in the sanctity that this ultra-low environment would endure for the intermediate term. At some point yields will approach a brick wall where the intuition of the collective consciousness of the market will realize the absurdity of negative returns in real terms and once that reversal occurs all hell will break loose. The most transient money that recently invested on the basis of safety instead of strategy will bail right away to cut their losses. They didn’t want to be there anyway. Then real wealth destruction will begin as investors begin to fathom the folly of the ponzi scheme of global debt that trumps corporate earnings to a primary degree.
I want my readers to know this- the US Treasury market is ripe for a historic collapse. Look for the moments when bonds sell off in tandem with stocks as the inflection point when we will know that the bond market has pit in a milt-decade top.
At some point I suspect that other investors will smell a run on Treasures and then wake up and smell the coffee- bonds are a fools game today at the twilight of a Kondratieff Winter. Now this will absolutely shock 99% of the pundits and analysts out there who are still deluded under the notion that the Federal Reserve can control the bond market. Bernanke recently hurled his last Hail Mary and I suspect he will soon be invoking higher powers for guidance on these matters. I sure hope he gets the help he needs.
Any degradation at all could ignite more selling and give bond vigilantes the cover they need to short or just sell US Treasuries at these near record levels. The downgrade just announced by S&P may also induce holders of US bonds to sell and move into safer corporate bonds. There could soon be a point of recognition collectively among investors that will indicate to everyone it’t time to bail on all Treasury bonds, especially at all-time highs. Can anyone give me one good reason today to not just sell Treasuries and be content with cash for the time being. To me the safety of cash trumps the risk of being in US bonds. Never mind returns, just be liquid.
Another piece suggesting a long term top is forming for bonds could be heard from CNBC’s Rick Santelli Thursday afternoon as he invoked the sacred geometry found in the work of W.D Gann, much to the shock and chagrin of his on-air colleagues. In short, these charts indicate that a major cycle reversal for bonds will happen sometime in the month of August 2011. This would complete a cycle that began in 1982 when the last cycle in interest rates peaked and if this occurs then higher interest rates will serve to stunt economic growth for years to come. Rising yields would also dramatically increase the US government’s interest expense since so many trillions of debt must be rolled over in the short term. Our current debt expense each month exceeds $30 billion and that figure stands to rise a great deal higher in a rising yield environment. Although it doesn’t surprise me, it does worry me that so many investors are complacent to this possibility and that’s why I feel rising yields may be single biggest threat we face today.
So it will be interesting to see how well the 30 year auction goes on Thursday. Will foreigners step up once again to buy these bonds at all-time highs? What happens once the music stops? Will we finally have a failed auction?
Note- for those wishing to bet against the US bond market I recommend shares in TBT, an exchange traded fund that moves inversely with the US long bond. It closed today at its all-time low today at $26.50/share. Consult your investment advisor before taking any action.
Theater of the Absurd forges on with new Greek bailouts, debt-ceiling impasse
The enduring credit contagion in Europe took another strange turn in late June. As the threat of more severe austerity loomed, the people of Athens revolted in front of the world…..for just a few moments. Such timidness on behalf of the Greek people, much like the Irish previously, was celebrated by the global capital markets ….. for a few days. Then, a new reality check was dealt to investors as sovereign debt concerns from Italy and the news that for the first time US debt was put on review for downgrade by a major ratings agency. The one thing we can all agree on today is that the perils of the tail end of the current credit super- cycle will be front and center in the national consciousness for a long, long time.
But look no further than the enormous snap-back rally since late June to see how far removed the the capital markets are from price discovery based upon truths that are allegedly absorbed by a broad audience. Modern capital markets are now now more noted for their manic depressive mood swings than for honest price discovery. Have no illusions- we are shouting from the rooftops today that the Kondradieff Winter proposition is more entrenched than ever. No girly-man rally on ultra-thin summertime volume is going to shake us off the K Winter theme so long as the hallmarks of an economic winter are so prominent at the fore. Gold closing at an all-time record high Friday is a blatant repudiation of the status quo coming from Washington and Wall Street. Until deflation is realized by investors, expect gold to soar higher as unprecedented uncertainties abound everywhere.
Of course at times equity markets can rally on a) no news (no disaster du jour) or b) disaster reported a tad less than market anticipated; or c) a stay of execution being granted for a very brief period. Option C seems to be the catalyst for the recent rally in the markets up until July 8th.
Otherwise what could justify an eight day rally of nearly 1000 points on the Dow? The news on the Greece bailouts came as expected and the markets bounced higher after testing their 200 day moving average around 1258. With disaster in Greece postponed for a short while, the bulls took over and the shorts panicked, especially when the ISM numbers came in higher than expected. But those who bought the market in early July on the notion the ISM readings together with the ADP payroll numbers indicated the economy had squared the circle of the so- called “soft patch” were taken to the woodshed much like the shorts who threw in the towel and covered.
Accordingly, there have been more whipsaw periods in the markets this year than ever before. Why? Because basically since the global financial crisis began in the summer of 2007, the markets have seen several cycle periods of fear followed then by relief rallies coming from strong and improving earnings from mostsectors except housing and financials. The financials are still today the worst performing sector of all and this doesnʼt bode well for the overall markets since our economy badly needs credit expansion from this important sector.
Also, has anyone noticed that in 2011 the period between these cycle phases seems to be getting shorter? Last week, the feast following the close call on Greece had not yet even been digested before the indigestion of Italy and the Non-Farm Payrolls began to set in. I suspect this will be the norm for some time until the greater portion of the remaining phase of the Kondratieff Winter is completed. So investors, please chew your financial food slowly and be prepared to digest whatʼs ahead. Preservation of capital, not returns, is paramount today.
Of course very few of the talking heads out there would say such a thing. After all, they will tell you that cash HAS to be deployed somewhere, right? This makes sense, right? Not really. Cash making no interest actually outperforms just about everything under the sun in a Kondratieff Winter because it can buy more and more each day due assets plunging in a deflationary winter. But most American investors have a hard time reconciling this because in the back (and front) of their minds they are afraid that the purchasing power of their cash will be eroded by a plunging dollar. And of course even fewer have the spine to short stocks. Paradoxically, this is very bearish for stocks since so few are now short stocks.
Something else is bothering me that gets virtually no attention in the mainstream financial press. It relates to a rather disturbing technical trend that matters a great deal to me- the trajectory of yields on 30 yr bonds overlayed with the trajectory of the USD index against a basket of global currencies. The conclusion to me here is radical- that the technical trends suggest we are in a raging bull market on the USD and on yields on the 30 year bond. Now of course the obvious rebuttal from ay cynic would be………“Youʼre kidding, right” and I would say no, not one bit. Everything points to a breakout on the USD and a breakdown on the 30 yr bond. The charts indicate to me that the 30 yr bond is the key. Itʼs chart in recent years shows a pattern of making higher lows- 2.5% at the 2008 crash, 3.0% last spring during the Greek contagion and 3.5% recently. I call this a stealth crash in the making for the 30 yr bond. The higher lows in the face of massive QE from the FED during this period indicated much higher yields on 30 yr paper now that the Sugar Daddy Fed is gone.
And in such a strange world I expect the dollar to be quite strong, thank you. Investors can just maintain a simple rule of thumb- if a theme (dollar is toast, deflation is licked, etc) is seen to be a sure thing by the mainstream, consider betting squarely against against that theme. Such a strategy would have shown handsome profits over the years. So for the record- we are long USD, short paper assets to benefit from deflation, and short the long end of the Treasury curve. These directional bets would all work in any economic winter environment.
Iʼm confident the dollar is now on strong footing for the short and intermediate term. I have addressed this theme several times over the years in monthly comments, most recently on the ones posted April 4th of this year. The dollar is still the strongest fiat currency in the world (for now) and unless US sovereign debt is downgraded by the rating agencies it will continue to command a high premium to currencies of any indebted nations (the entire western world, sans Norway, Switzerland and a few others). It held its channel low of 2008 in April and has found quite a bid since that time. In fact, if it continues higher and can close convincingly over 76 on the USD index, itʼs sure to break out to the early to mid 80ʼs. If this occurs it could trigger a correction in equities from 15-20% based on the close correlation in recent years to the risk-on/risk/off trade so much at the heart of the dysfunction in todayʼs capital markets.
This present dysfunction is not limited to the maniacal “risk on/risk off” switch that vacillates between the prevailing “all in” vs. “Iʼm out of here” modalities at the frontal lobes of investors each of trading. A potpourri of other maladies can be seen through investorʼs behavior that is quite alarming. Most alarming is a complete aversion to economic realities whose impact could possibly be felt during a period beyond the marketʼs next trading day. Hell be damned, in other words. In past eras, only real shocks could reverse market sentiment. What does this imply about the future given the hundreds of trillions in outstanding derivatives that could be affected by nasty mood swings by the capital markets?
It implies complacency on a grand scale. The most obvious case of this involves the present quagmire over the debt ceiling. I do expect at least a short term fix but canʼt predict how it will be received by investors. I will proffer this nugget to our readers today- there may be a huge wild card out there that virtually no one (including myself) can predict. These may include a downgrade of US debt by Moodyʼs despite an announced extension of the debt ceiling, or perhaps China throwing down the gauntlet in disgust over our inability to get our house in order. In any case, the stock and bond markets are truly complacent, choosing to see the glass half-full via strong corporate profits. But complacency thrives in such a vacuum, and letʼs remember that in July 2008 complacency also ruled the day.
Now to the grande finale- the raising of the US debt ceiling. So much to say here, but so little space. But a core theme here is the shared complicity among all parties that the chief problem (debt) is born from very long term causes and must be remedied with this in mind. It is our belief that our leaders must reconcile our debt crisis in terms of long wave super-cycle dynamics that instead of the short term fixes exacerbate a growing cancer. I ask our readers to examine the material on our site and ask themselves if itʼs absurd to expect a miracle from measures that have never worked before. If citizens push the envelope on this, our leaders will reconsider and adjust if they are forced. Letʼs hope that cooler heads and bright minds will prevail in this epic struggle to reign in the titanic debt loads in the US and the Western world.
A real Game of “Chicken”
The slide in the US markets for the past five straight weeks accelerated to a primary degree in recent days as economic data from a variety of areas indicated the so-called economic recovery in place was halted in its tracks. Most shocking was the employment data just released from the US Department of Labor that revealed a paltry 54,000 jobs created in the month of April. This level was so small it caused the unemployment rate to climb back over 9% as more workers sought jobs. The data also confirmed another damaging trend- workers are working less hours and are getting paid less for their work.
Since the labor markets are the mother’s milk of any growing and prosperous economy, it’s worth exploring what causes this so we can make the right changes. It is my belief that a great deal of blame lies in the very structure of our economic system. Certain content on our site has introduced these themes, including the central planning of our economy by the Executive branch and Congress, the unabated de-basement of our currency by the Federal Reserve that destroys the purchasing power of our citizens, the objective of corporations to serve their shareholders at the expense of the public, etc. We can only hope these conditions will change through a wholesale reform of the political, social and economic infrastructure supporting the present landscape. Although such potent reform is unlikely to occur through incremental change, it could unfold in response to a severe condition, namely one brought about by a Kondratieff Winter.
Such a condition would be preceded by deflation, the mother’s milk of any Kondratieff Winter. And although deflation has been in a somewhat stealth for some time now (unless you own a home) due to the rise in paper assets courtesy of the Fed’s bag of tricks, it is anything but stealth now. Commodities not named gold have declined sharply for several weeks and so have stocks. But the recent data from Case Shiller just released may be the best evidence of all that deflation still persists. This report should be a real wake-up call to those who have been swearing off deflation as if they were choosing not to participate in a world having such an evil.
Yet deflation has many attributes, most notably of all is the affordability it can create. Deflation allows nature to take its course by letting asset prices move to their true clearing price. Deflation does not obfuscate the true economic picture so that capital can be deployed with full confidence in the ventures that so badly need it. Yet sadly we inhabit a zombie-like state of economic paranoia that cripples investment, bank lending, and economic vitality. As long as the Fed is monetizing our debt and our government is spending trillions to stimulate a zombie, we can expect to see at best a prolonged stagflation much like Japan has endured over the past twenty years or at worst something quite unlike what most can imagine. Deflation should be embraced, not feared. It can be a good thing, just like inflation can be good if it is present in wages.
Deflation occurs as a result of excessive debt, and excessive debt is the signature hallmark of the US and Western economies. The ability of sovereign nations to service that debt is now being challenged for the first time with a flurry of recent downgrades in the debt of a multitude of sovereign nations. Even the US was put on watch by S&P recently but the markets just yawned. But I sense a subtle change in basic investor apprehension regarding these staggering debt loads that boggle the mind. The US must borrow over $4 billion each day just to stay afloat and we are now resorting to nothing short of fanciful accounting to avoid defaulting on our government debt obligations.
This is pathetic, and now the biggest game of chicken in our history is being played out in the halls of Congress. One petulant group (the Democrats) wants to avoid the spending cuts needed to get our house in order while another petulant group (the Republicans) are demanding the spending cuts without any increase in taxes whatsoever, as if raising taxes is akin to mass murder. We need both for real reform, but frankly I believe that spending cuts are more important because in terms of scale they dwarf the levels any tax increase would bring at the margin. We must remember that the US was quite a global powerhouse from the 1950’s through the 1980”s when tax rates were so much higher and our spending was so much lower. Some give on both sides is needed, even if its highly titled toward spending cuts.
How will this game of “chicken” play out? A vote last week in Congress revealed just how much of a hurdle there is to get an agreement, as almost four in five members of Congress voted against raising the debt ceiling. This is sure to come down to the 12th hour, just like the budget battle in April but with so much more at stake. While it does seem like a game of “chicken” in its ultimate form, I suggest another game of chicken has been playing out for decades- how our government leaders are chicken to do what’s best for our country. Instead they seem to always choose the politically expedient measure, even if it’s no solution at all. And for our part, US citizens have also been too chicken to demand and define the changes we deserve. Let’s hope that this debt ceiling increase does get approved and let’s also hope it clears the way for a renewed spirit of compromise going forward that will provide more of the change we all deserve.It’s time to have an adult conversation of matters of such importance.
Amazingly, until just days ago the consensus was that global economic growth for the coming years would be mighty. Now forecasters are slashing growth rates faster than you can say “gotcha” to those who form the consensus opinion, i.e. Wall Street analysts, pundits, journalists, and many noted hedge fund managers. In recent days the number of searches on the net for “kondratieff winter” have surged yet of course to date I have never seen the term Kondratieff Winter mentioned in a major mainstream outlet. I will bet anyone a gold bar you will see it soon.
Fed to US citizens: Drop Dead! Runaway inflation is transitory because we say it is
Last week Chairman Bernanke maintained his stance on an overly accommodative monetary policy making the US the only country refusing to put the brakes on the easy money. That Fed policy is so starkly divergent to the rest of the world has lead the US dollar to all-time lows against many currencies and within an eyelash of an all-out run on the USD. The Fed could care less. All that matters to the Fed is propping up asset prices to the detriment of over 90% of our population who lose purchasing power from higher prices and no interest on their savings. Even stock appreciation is negated as the USD is now down more ytd than the gains in the S&P. There’s no free lunch on Wall St.
In the first press conference in the history of the star-crossed Fed, Bernanke calmly knocked the softballs lobbed by journalists out of the park. The ones that had any zip he refused to answer and this was allowed to stand. (Too bad Ron Paul wasn’t in the crowd.) I would have asked him to defend my claim that the Fed is running a Ponzi scheme and asked who was in line to buy all their toxic assets, among others. But for the time being, they get a hall pass and the illusion of transparency. But in having the audacity to claim that inflation today is “transitory”, Ben may have sown the seeds for his undoing. Let’s examine his claim further.
First, let’s be clear that the markets didn’t buy it one bit. They are calling his bluff on this in a spectacular way as gold and silver continued to explode higher to all-time nominal highs while the dollar sunk to near all-time lows. They can appreciate the sheer folly of maintaining such reckless open ended easy money policies. Markets can appreciate that inflation is not in the least transitory because higher energy and food prices are in large part due to compounding human population growth and supply constraints. This basic equation suggests higher prices and together with easy money fiat printing leads to investor speculation that drives prices higher than they otherwise be.
What the Fed is so blind to is that their policies dare speculation to pile on and drive prices so much higher. So it’s no surprise inflation is taking hold so quickly this year as the Fed keeps waving the all clear sign. Food and energy prices have been soaring for years now, so this is no passing fad. Yet sadly we allow the government to measure inflation in a way that ignores reality and this is a key enabler to our enormous deficits and sinking dollar. The Fed has willfully created a self-fulfilling prophecy of higher inflation through this un-virtuous cycle loop. I expect this cycle to reach a critical mass later this year that will force them to reverse policy much quicker than they would have preferred. I suspect then that the merits of maintaining such an easy money track for so long will come under great fire. Ben and the Fed have dug in their heals not just on QE2 but on the very notion that monetary policy is not inflationary. The only thing I see that can be called “transitory” is the current Fed policy of currency debasement.
I suspect the asset inflation express train to keep rolling higher but not without sharp reversals and increased volatility. The market short term is extremely overbought and is displaying exhaustion to a primary degree. Many believe we have broken out to the upside but few have noted the exceptional divergence in place now with the Dow Transports taking out their 2007 highs while the S&P and Dow Jones averages are still well off their all-time highs. This is a serious blow to Dow Theory and cannot be ignored. And S&P earnings are likely peaking this quarter as the recent explosion in inflation, the Japan earthquake, and other factors served to derail GDP growth in Q1 to only 1.8% from over 3% the previous quarter. Meanwhile, the western world keeps issuing paper iou’s like never before, setting the stage later this year for an acceleration of the de-leveraging process that began in 2007 that has taken a pause in recent quarters.
Despite the recent plunge in the USD, I still believe it will find a hard bottom by the summer as investors come to realize that Japan and the Euro region have much more challenging obstacles to growth than the US. The continued slide of the dollar until then will incite more rancor here that will pressure the Fed to keep its word in ending QE2 this summer. I expect at some point a sea change in global asset allocation to a risk-off mode that will enable the USD to catch a serious bid. Paper assets will increase for a bit longer but are likely in the twilight of an epic run that began in 1982 when the autumn phase of the Kondratieff cycle began. When the Fed’s policies are appreciated to be inflationary and counter-productive, a tipping point could be reached that could cause a serious unwind of paper assets the likes of which we have never seen.
March Madness: Jupiter’s Juggernaut Mocks the Black Swans
Those expecting the sharp sell-off in mid-March to continue given so much global turmoil must feel bewildered today with the amazing rally of the past two weeks. In fact, most US averages and indexes closed Friday at multi-year highs in the face of major headline risk events such as earthquakes, tsunami’s, nuclear meltdowns coupled with multiple revolutions and a new war in the Mideast. I’m sure many are now asking themselves this- what’s going on here and why is the K-Winter so long overdue?
In the past, I would have been in the same camp as those bewildered and would have been caught short again in a rising market. But last spring I stumbled upon the theme of mundane financial astrology through Ray Merriman’s site www.mmacycles.com and found a cogent approach to making sense of the madness before us in the markets today. Since then I have read his free weekly forecasts and have found them to be the most accurate anywhere. Perhaps mundane astrology holds they key to forecasting the timing of the onset of the next economic winter. It’s a fine complement to the Elliott Wave approach based on stock charting and the Kondratieff Wave theory based on long term economic cycles. Although it’s less known to most that the EW or KW, financial astrology offers a basis for the cause-effect that influence the markets that the others aren’t designed to provide, and such a tool can be very useful these days.
I have presented Merriman’s themes here in the past and they were evident last month. His core theme is that the prevailing influences of Jupiter and Uranus in Aries over the past several months (and into early June) give us what he calls the “asset inflation train that doesn’t stop for red lights”. This is exactly what has happened as the markets have shrugged off any bad news no matter how huge. This bad ass train is still a runaway juggernaut today, trouncing any obstacles in its way. During such a mighty alignment we must discard logic and see that the momentum and the manic nature of its influence rule over any coherent analysis. The Jupiter influences of speculation, grand scale and excess rule the day. Does anything else better explain this madness?
But most runaway trains do end up in the scrap heap, and I still expect the deflationary forces underpinning a Kondratieff Winter to emerge during this summer. On June 4 of this year Jupiter advances to Taurus and according to mundane financial astrology this Jupiter effect will be diminished. Coincidentally, near that time the Fed is expected to announce halt the famed “QE 2” program that has been goosing the markets since last fall. Other deflationary pressures are mounting such as the US housing market and European sovereign debt which both seem headed for the proverbial “double-dip” pretty soon. But in the near tern it seems clear that unlike recent history, equity markets are refusing to discount such scenarios. That’s what we get with Jupiter’s juggernaut. The other aspect of Jupiter and Uranus in Aries relates to sudden and shocking events.
Many such events occurred in March beginning with revolutions across the Arab world to the tragic earthquake in Japan on arch 11th. It seems like the chaos is everywhere and no matter how tragic these developments are sure to raise our consciousness to some degree. The material in several areas on our site suggest there is a very a distinct order to this that belies its perceived chaos. This material suggests that these events can be foreseen to some degree through cycle patterns over long periods and their intended purpose to raise our collective consciousness to effect changes that are long overdue. Certainly I have no illusions that most will agree or trust such a thesis, but perhaps some of our readers who have seen this material before these events may be more inclined after this recent chain reaction. As Ian Lundgold proposed in the video in our Mayan Calendar section, we are on a schedule that encourages the evolution of consciousness through what happens in our world. And the events of recent weeks have likely caused many to internalize how we view the world and that’s a good thing.
Such dramatic times as these by nature lend themselves to so-called black swan events that now appear to happen all the time. I read Nassim Taleb’s gem The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable and took special note of how Taleb parses what constitutes a true black swan event. After absorbing this I dare to say that the global financial crisis of 2008 and what has transpired recently just doesn’t make the grade as a black swan. Why? It was possible to see it coming if you were aware. I put content on our site some years ago forecasting a gaggle of black swan events that did occur- a housing crash, a stock market meltdown, a sudden freeze in credit and the theme of social changes now unfolding caused by an expanded consciousness around the globe. But mere mortals such as myself are incapable by axion of predicting black swan events. A real black swan event is sufficiently unforeseen and dramatic it effects change at the core. But today we remain stuck in the mindset and practices of what enabled the meltdown in 2008. It seems we are demanding a more radical event to shake us from our ignorance, complacency, and indifference to these unsustainable conditions. This is why I still believe a Kondratieff Winter is likely to occur between late 2011 and 2013.
Historically, so-called fat tail risks are much more likely. They are exogenous events that were miscalculated by experts and analysts. An example of this was the Russian debt default in 1998 that befuddled analysts because Russia was not so imperiled to default. But the market underestimated the tail risk of political will to comply with debt payback and thus the unlikely default. This happens all the time in our world yet the capital markets fail to account for this risk or the more unnerving black swan event. It’s not in their DNA to tell the world- hey, this will happen so raise your risk premiums. So the breakdown in pricing tail risk here is a combination of the twin towers of deception in the word of risk- arrogance and complacency. Yet both abound today because the modeling done by most assumes a normal distribution of risk along the spectrum as evidenced through the pathetically outdated Gaussian distribution model upon which risk is priced today in our capital markets. It’s unfortunate that something so important as this is rarely ever discussed in the financial mainstream- until after the fact.
Perhaps the preponderance in recent weeks of so many black swan impostors means that a real one is on the horizon. Perhaps a short squeeze on the US Dollar?
Ask any pundit or Joe on the street and he’ll tell you today the US dollar is toast. I’ll take the other side of that trade. The US is still the largest economy in the world and our best companies are gaining ground. We are not as fragmented politically,geographically, and socially as our only peer (Euro). But perhaps most under appreciated of all, the dollar will benefit from something few have considered- how well entrenched its status as the world’s reserve currency comes from the sheer breadth and magnitude of existing dollar denominated contractual obligations between global counter-parties. Although the eventual demise of the US dollar is likely, how it could play out is sure to deviate from any present forecast. Absent circumstances so extraordinary, any accelerated unwind of a USD standard is highly unlikely in the short term. Later this week the EC is expected to raise interest rates for the first time in since 2009 but it may already be priced in the the EUR/USD. But if Trichet’s comments are anything less than hawkish, expect the Euro to sell off. They are a long way from escaping their debt woes.
A key ingredient in the recipe for future dollar strength will be the collapse of the Japanese yen against all currencies, but especially against the USD. This collapse is more likely today than ever before despite the fact that days ago the yen rose to the strongest level vs. the dollar in modern history. This is madness! Japan is in the most financial peril today of any country in the world since WW2 ended. Their debt to GDP is 225% and they were just hit with one of the biggest earthquakes in history that is sure increase their debt substantially immediately. They must import nearly everything and their single strength (manufacturing) will be hampered for years to come from the quake and tsunami that hit on March 11th. THe knee-jerk reaction in the currency markets was to bid the yen to all-time highs under a neanderthal philosophy that an abundance of global capital would be forced to convert to yen and the currency speculators did what most speculators do- leap off a tall building with no regard to the landing.
I just wonder if Ben realizes how tragic and hopeless it is to defeat a deflationary economic winter through a credit based solution. I wonder sometimes which specific day that he will see that fiat currency based debt monetization can only goose markets for a while before the piper must be paid. He must be paid, and I suspect that soon Japan’s creditors will see a black hole and demand the changes we are seeing now in Ireland, Portugal, Greece etc. Yes I do see a hard landing in the PIGS countries, Japan, and finally the US. I expect the deflationary forces to emerge once the perception that Japan is likely to default on much of its debt obligations.
Japan is where I see the bond vigilantes will make their first bold move. They will finally realize what I suspect- trillions of Japanese debt will default. Although the Yen is now at an all-time high vs the USD, it won’t endure. So look out for a strong comeback in now deposed King Dollar in the near term unless it breaks its 2008 lows of 74. Such a breach would imply a far greater move lower in the dollar and much higher inflation. Let’s hope our leaders defend our currency and the purchasing power of most citizens through pro growth economic policies not encumbered with fiscal or monetary policy steroids already proven to be debilitating and destabilizing.
Revolutions Abroad, But Devolution Here
Since my last comments were posted much has changed in the world, but not so much here in the US. While Egypt was busy toppling it’s military dictator for the past 40 years and other regimes in the Middle East were being confronted with a revolutionary spirit taking hold across the region, US officials countered by extending the mandatory debt ceiling for a period of twelve whole days. That says it all my friends abut the relative state of change vis a vis the US and the rest of the world. We are taking safe baby steps while the rest of the world forges ahead with bold plans for real change. Here, we consider real change as having the nerve to parse some vernacular. We must do more.
The US is now the tortoise to the progressive hare of the booming emerging economies of our age (Singapore, Taiwan, Malasia, etc.). Yet the US seems tethered to our past by overspending and pretending to be serious about real change. The contrast in the approach to real change between the US and the impoverished people of the Middle East should be remarkable to watch unfold in the near future. Do you think we’ll ever through the bums out? Who is being progressive here, folks? It takes sacrifice and being able to make hard and unpleasant choices.
History suggests that progress is made through tough choices. Churchill offered no illusions while Neville Chamberlain assured England everything was just fine. Perhaps we are at such a crossroads again of moral leadership in the western world. Historically at crossroads you though them bums out, and I hope we do but with respect.
And maybe we should given the steady erosion of living standards in the US. Despite the persistent melt-up rally on thin volume since QE2 debt monetization was enacted by the Fed last fall, the purchasing power of most Americans has markedly declined over time and has even accelerated in recent months as inflation has taken center stage all over the world. Surging food inflation is behind the riots in Tunisia, Egypt, Bahrain as food comprises over 40% of the average wage of those citizens. Fuel inflation spurred sharp declines in the US stock markets on Monday and Friday last week as investors were reminded that fuel inflation preceded steep drops in the stock markets in 2008.
Despite the rhetoric from Bernanke, the Fed’s gonzo loose money bonanza does export inflation to the rest of the world. But each time we see on TV the unrest in the Middle East we can at least be reminded that some actual good may come from this. Then at the pump we are also reminded of how QE2 hits us all directly. Oh what a joy to have the Fed part of our daily lives. Well, until we revolt against the Fed we can expect more of the same.
But why is the Fed in the first place so committed to radical inflationary policies such as QE2 despite increasing evidence of a broad economic recovery in the US? I think they fear a deflationary asset bubble much more than they lead on. They rely on a dubious “output gap” approach that assumes that if unemployment is relatively high and wage inflation is relative low then capacity utilization is low and thus inflation will remain low. But such a model is nothing more than political cover for their policies. As Fed Governor Hoenig recently commented, inflation coming from the Fed is likely to be “insidious” in nature, creeping and hovering about and revealing itself when it’s too big to effectively thwart especially given the capricious and downright ludicrous way our government chooses to measure the key economic indicators. Inflation excludes the two elements we can’t do without (food and energy), unemployment fails to measure those not looking for work (millions), and GDP data includes paper transactions that don’t create anything real. It’s an axiom these measures will always overstate our true economic condition.
Other measures can’t be fudged, and these indicators are very troubling. They include among others reduced tax receipts that bely the reported GPD growth, insider selling of public companies at a 15 to 1 clip, the highest reported food prices in over twenty years, a stunning plunge of 70% in one year of the Baltic Dry Index that measures global shipping activity, and a renewed pace of housing price declines that suggest a double-dip in housing has already begun. These developments may account for the recent revision in GDP for the 4th quarter of 2010 to under 3% despite the most prolific fiscal and monetary stimulus ever conceived. And market internals also suggest trouble ahead for the stock market as the divergence between volume and price gains have been huge for over one year as conviction is only seen in sell-offs. But although I am confident that the markets will continue to decline in the near term as the dollar makes a strong comeback, I see one more rally ahead into the summer before the exhaustion gap is filled that will precede a severe and protracted decline in stocks.
The coming weeks will feature a political standoff over increasing the budget ceiling that now stands at $14.2 trillion. This will mark the third increase needed in just a few years since the global financial crisis began and the new cap will have to be around $20 trillion
given the projected deficits of the next few years. During this period we will be forced as a nation to take a hard look at our path and be reminded of how painful the process is likely to be. It could be compared with a middle-aged person going in for a routine exam and finding out they have a condition that could be terminal without a drastic lifestyle change. Are we ready to confront our own mortality? Until now, the answer has been a firm no. I believe that the best way to confront this is by engaging in vigorous discourse in two key areas above all else- addressing the toxic assets on the Fed’s balance sheet and reducing the outlays of the four horsemen of the apocalypse- Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security and defense spending. Any plan not including these as major areas of reform is just conversation.
We have entered a new period marking the most dramatic transformation in human history ever seen on many fronts- socially, politically, and economically. It is with this in mind that I included on this site some unique content relating to this profound change. The KW and the Mayan Calendar examines the intersection of social and economic change over long super-cycle periods and includes a two hour video from Ian Lundgold that’s not typical from a site devoted to economic theory. It was added to this site two years ago and among it’s core themes was the idea that a radical global transformation would be soon taking lace that would be the culmination of a very long super-cycle of human evolution in consciousness. Given the recent events in the Middle East, I would urge our readers to check this out. We felt the need to offer this given that the vacuum of such content by a mainstream media more interested in profits and distraction.
The Fed’s balance sheet can be seen resembling what lies on the other side beyond the looking glass. The illusion remains real so long as it is perceived as real. Sadly, we are all beholden to this confidence game that is larger than all of us. Bernanke believes the sophistication of their monetization scheme can endure any storm. I dare to say that any investment in US equities may be considered a bet on maintaining this confidence game. So long as the Fed’s ponzi can be sustained, then the earnings power of many mighty US companies will command high valuations. And for now, they have. But…
But these earnings are susceptible to systemic shocks to the financial system. The Kondratieff theory suggests that de-leveraging must occur at such a late stage of the economic super-cycle but instead the Fed and Obama Administration have created the opposite effect- an extended re-leveraging of debt and fiat currency of a primary degree with an amplitude that would make Meyer Rothschild blush with envy. As Gordon Gekko gushed in the original Wall Street movie, “the illusion has become real “. It sure seems so as nearly everyone believes today that the financial alchemy of the Fed can save us from any cyclical Depression. We will eventually see whether this is true or not in the grandest game of chicken ever seen.
How will the Kondratieff Winter Play out in 2011?
I’m quite sure many interested in long wave theory are now bewildered by the fact that the global capital markets have not yet imploded. In recent months I have added content indicating the fourth Kondratieff Winter was pushed out due to the reckless policy directives of the Fed and global central banks to monetize their own debt. In the short run, yes, they have stimulated modest economic recovery in the US and beyond. Yet at the same time these measures have complicated the unwinding of monetization to a primary degree and directly threaten the recovery they very seek to sustain.
So as we consider the outlook for 2011 in the capital markets and the relative stage of where we stand in the Kondratieff Cycle, let’s make some observations that can’t be refuted. First, the sovereign debt in Western nations continues to spiral out of control and is undoubtedly unsustainable. In recent months, debt auctions of all countries that are over-leveraged have become nothing less than a complete farce. Last week the ECB bought Portugal debt in the days preceding their crucial debt auction to prevent an outright failed auction. Here, the desperation is palatable. And in recent Treasury auctions of ten and thirty year maturities the Fed likewise has done likewise in buying (monetizing) most of our debt. That the Fed has now recently surpassed China as the biggest holder of US Treasuries and has also exceeded the $ 1 trillion level has severe implications. People, this is what happens in a Kondratieff WInter.
Such behavior makes denying that a deflationary winter can’t happen is pretty tough to swallow. The only difference between this period and the 1930’s is that this Fed is more sophisticated in its obfuscation of their true policy intentions. You can chalk that up to one committed and unflappable monetarist, one Ben Bernanke. That said, I must say I admire sheer genius when I see it, even if it’s misguided in my belief.
Ray Merriman’s financial astrology forecast of 2011 weighed in on this in unusually harsh terms but in line with his past leanings on this. I have reported this in previous blogs because I feel its importance cannot be overstated. So as I read Merriman’s much anticipated forecast last month for 2011, I was all at once pleased and also surprised to read that his single greatest “off the charts” prediction for 2011 was that the Fed would undergo a transformation that would bring great shock to the world. Most intriguing to me was the wording surrounding this forecast when framed against everything else- it was as close to emphatic as it gets for a professional financial astrologer of his merit. While the preponderance of financial forecasts in this book relating to commodities, stocks, bonds, the US markets, etc., etc., etc. are all hedged with the standard double-speak normally associated with broad projections, this one about the FED stood out big-time. And he has been setting this up for nine months on his site by citing Helicopter Ben’s natal chart and his penchant for grand long shots within a mental framework that belies his placid public demeanor. Merriman knows the REAL Bernanke, and since I dared to believe Merriman’s account of Big Ben I now see the light. He is an “all in” type, very heavily invested in his own prerogative. So anyone knowing this early on like Merriman or his clients would know Ben will always err on the side of huge risk. That’s what he does, and that’s what he’s doing. He’s has too much conviction to be a phony.
Another observation supporting the deflationary bubble is bursting is the yield creep along the Treasury curve since QE2 was announced in late August. Never mind that prices for many things are soaring higher, namely food and energy, I prefer to look at the direction of asset prices. Our largest asset class, homes, has steadily declined in the face of unprecedented fiscal and monetary stimulus. And with interest rates on the move higher, I suspect home prices to remain muddled for years due to a glut of foreclosures that will take years to work through. High unemployment, stagnant wages, rising inflation of basic necessities such as food and energy all work to put a ceiling on real economic growth and prosperity among the people.
Declining home values and rising interest rates are crucial forces indicating deflation will win out as this credit super-cycle plays out, yet I don’t see deflation taking hold until later this year. The shorter term business cycle is winning out at present due to the replenishing of an inventory build that was depleted more than we had ever seen but it is close to being finished. Stocks have moved higher in recent months in large part from this cycle build combined with a zealous Fed determined to put a bid under this market- no matter what the consequence. So my central theme for 2011 is this- the evidence abounds that the aggregate debt levels of sovereign governments (including state and muni debt) indicate we are in the twilight of this debt super-cycle and that the hallmark features of the Kondratieff Winter are evident and accelerating. But due to the Fed and other forces mentioned above, the day of reckoning is still not upon us yet. But some markers already indicate the the tattle-tale signs that the Winter is looming.
Chief among them is the debt ceiling of $14 trillion that must be increased by the end of March or the US government will default on its debt. The last time this showdown was so serious was early in 1995, and many areas of the US government did in fact shut down briefly as the Republicans took over Congress and called President Clinton’s bluff. But the US debt levels then were just a fraction of what they are today, and the threat of default on US government securities was not in play. It is now, and I expect some high noon drama in the coming weeks before a last minute settlement will be reached on increasing the debt limit for the third time in a just a few years.
But the damage will be done to the implicit credit quality of US govt debt, and interest rates are likely to enter a new trajectory higher. While the removal of this event risk will be cheered by the markets at first, the yield creep across the entire spectrum of US Treasury debt will prove to be quite a formidable market force for stocks to overcome later this year. Yield creep can quickly morph into something much worse if the present perception of US debt is ever replaced with even a hint or a whiff that all US debt is just one big Ponzi. Even without this development, a reversion to the mean for rates has already begun and is likely to undermine any sustained economic growth until the cycle is complete. Since Congress recently extended the Bush tax cuts without any cuts in spending, it is near certain that the bond vigilantes will make make sure higher rates are here to stay. While there have been times in the past that the US capital markets have ignored rising rates, I say this time is different because now our multi-trillion dollar deficits raise the specter of rates rising higher at an alarming rate, And remember, we are now in uncharted waters in this debt cycle. How long will outright Fed monetization be tolerated? That’s the #1 question in 2011 for the US markets I believe. The beloved Bernanke Put is not your Daddy’s Greenspan Put on the markets.
It’s really more like the Bernanke Naked Put that exposes today’s young adults (Gen X&Y) to the perils of super-cycle debt. It works just fine until the ponzi is exposed for all to see. Unlike the Greenspan Put, the Bernanke Put is subject to the final stages of a long-term credit cycles whose excesses today are at their peak. So In the context of super-cycle economics as I see them, the present generation of young adults are the ones with the most to lose. The youngest amongst us will fare better, as they will be entering into some of the best economic super-cycle periods when they grow up. By then, the fallacy that there are no economic super-cycles will be a thing of the past. Yet it may be all too real for today’s young adults who may find themselves caught in the crosshairs of generational politics. They may suffer unless they are well acquainted with super-cycle economics.
So before us in 2011 is what I characterized in a previous blog as the heavyweight fight of our lifetime- the Fed and the US Treasury vs. the Kondratieff Winter. Back and forth they will go in 2011. Expect knockdowns on each side. In fact today some would say the KW is on its back. But starting tomorrow, a pretty nice reversal should begin with the news of Job’s leave at Apple Computer combined with a seriously overbought market reflecting a beautiful five wave completion since early September. But as I guessed in mid- December, the bulls still have some fight left and I don’t think for a minute that the bulls won’t come back this spring.
This year should be quite eventful and pivotal as the inflation asset express train that doesn’t stop for red lights runs out of steam into the deflationary forces brewing just below the surface that have been for so long accruing and percolating in a subtle but tenacious fashion. We’ll see once and for all in 2011 if these debt levels really do matter- or not. Our theory says they do, and until I see evidence that rebukes centuries of empirical evidence of super-cycle boom and bust, I refuse to believe this debt super-cycle, the largest ever thirty-fold, will just slip away into the night without serious recourse. The K-Wave theory hold that these excesses must be rid- or else. Thankfully, debt levels have risen lately to a level sufficient or render judgment soon on this wacky theory once and for all. DO economic super-cycles matter? We will see for sure in 2011.
A Tale of Two Cities, Now More Than Ever
In recent weeks the markets have weathered an overdue correction at the end of November and have reached multi-year highs as I surmised in my last post. Yet the Dow Industrials failed to take out the 2010 high made on November 5th, and this divergence may be seen as a bearish indicator for the near term. And the 1250 level on the S&P just ahead is a formidable resistance level I don’t expect to be taken out right away.
It appears that present market levels have forward priced much of the good vibrations out there such as Bush tax cut extensions, 0% interest rates for our lifetime, QE 3,4,5.. etc. and not whay may be foreboding. These levels assume that some challenges to sustaining growth just won’t occur. These include assumptions that interest rates can’t rise if the Fed is buying treasuries, deficits just don’t matter, geopolitical risks are intangible, the growing Euro contagion will dissipate, and that commodity inflation won’t materially impact corporate profits or consumer behavior. I doubt the markets will escape the wrath of some of these threats.
Yet global stock markets worldwide forged higher with glaring disparities evident in their relative strength. US market averages get an asterisk from such anemic volume coming in large part from the refusal of the retail investor to take the bait and drink the proverbial cool-aid. Net mutual fund flows for stocks have declined now for 31 consecutive weeks since the May 6th flash crash, and I see that as a compelling “tell” on the state of these markets. It’s clear to most that that the advance from the summer lows has been driven almost completely by a combination of asset managers who have been forced into the rally late to catch up to the benchmark returns (or be fired) and HFT fund flows that have a time span of a conviction to own stocks that can be measured in nanoseconds.. With the Mercury retrograde and the heavy resistance at 1250 upon us, I suspect that maintaining this advance ahead of earnings season will be pretty tough.
So I am bearish near term but still respect the theme of this reckless asset inflation express train that doesn’t stop for red lights and still has some momentum. But it does face a date of destiny with the gods of the Kondratieff cycle sometime in our near future. In the past, I would have said 1250 is the brick wall that can’t be broken, but my blogs of the past month or two invoke a pattern of further pricing disconnect in the short therm ( one month to one year) that will precede the culmination of the end game so to speak of a deflationary asset bubble occurring thereafter. The human will of reigning central bankers has made a fait accompli decision for all us us through their policy decisions of invoking unlimited application of electronic credit by fiat that has become the law of the land all over the “civilized” world. So what does this mean for all of us? My take is a tale of two cities.
To some, these are the best of times. To most, they are not, and the divergence has never been greater nor the extremes. Perhaps only Dickens could relish and appreciate the modern and confounding world of global finance for what it appears to be- a sobering reflection a two-headed Jannes archetype quite mystifying to most observers.
So why with the pithy quotes and provocative metaphors? I guess it’s comes from the raw and vexing disconnect I see growing each day between the deteriorating reality on the ground and the headlines leading the global markets forward. Hard to say where to begin, but let’s try to parse the core themes of this disconnect playing out before us that color the capital markets so dyslexic to providing meaningful price discovery. Here are some prime examples:
The Euro contagion hits critical mass, yet most market indexes rose recently to multi-year highs on reports that the US would backstop the EU’s ever-expanding bailout of troubled Eurozone countries. But does anyone really believe this plan will have a chance two years after bond vigilantes called Hank Paulsen’s bluff on his threatened “pocket bazooka” that was unmasked as a water pistol? The smart money bid up the credit default swaps of distressed credits knowing, and also salivating, that Paulsen’s proverbial bazooka was just a paper tiger and those vigilantes weren’t about to let Paulsen off the hook with a bluff. So in 2008 credit default swaps of risky credits’s blew out shortly thereafter, and with it the bluff of any potential threat of a proverbial sovereign “bazooka. You would think. The present market seems to have lost sight of Hank Paulsen on his knees before Nancy Pelosi begging for the Congressional fiat decree for the crime of the century in 2008.
But with the recent bailout of Irish banks the EU has taken this bait and now we have déjà vu now on the bazooka bluff. Are investors nuts? Is there anything real in this world? Bernanke confirmed on a Sixty Minutes that further debt monetization beyond the stated $600 billion was possible (likely) methinks he was forgetting that he and Geithner swore before Congress in 2008 that they would never monetize the Treasury debt. Through QE2 they have are subject to inquiries about perjury if anyone in Congress had a spine. But for now let’s just call their statements out for their contradictions to their actions. These actions and policy directives of the EU and the Fed reveal a new breed of riverboat gamblers hell bent on doubling or tripling down on their bets to overcome the structural conflict of their allegiances. Thus through such a rigid dogma they’ve become so hard wired over the years to only one way off the reservation- credit expansion with no table limit and all the markers they need from the American public. But don’t lose sight of who is really the house here- the gambler, not the casino (US citizens). It’s all bad when the gamblers rule the casino or the inmates rule the prisons or the hacks rule the public.
I have put forth the danger of the Fed’s close-minded strategy in the original material put on this site in the late summer of 2007. The core theme at the outset then was that the Fed and other central banks are structurally flawed in that they are hard wired to the Keynesian and monetary schools of thought and aren’t flexible in considering any path of policy directives diametrically opposed to their dogmatic, orthodoxy no matter how things were to play out. What we have now before us perhaps is some version of the nuclear option being played out in front of our very eyes in a slow motion train wreck that most won’t see until its too late. How many gamblers do you know have gotten out of a fix by doubling and tripling down on a bet? History shows that fools and gamblers only learn when they change their mindset and behavior, not the audacity on what they will risk. Of course the Fed and the EU are gambling with the future liabilities of others, not their own money, so it’s quite believable that they could such a colossal risk to overcome what will be seen one day as severely misdirected policy directives by those in power.
2) Now in 2010, some thirty years into a globalization trend that has proven beyond doubt that any notion of “decoupling” between global markets now more connected than ever investors still cling to hopes that the US can be removed from from the mess in the Eurozone even though the EU is our largest trading partner. But take note of this- the prices of credit default swaps on sovereign debt from the leading EU members Germany and France spiked higher last week for the first time in years, indicating the perceived buffer zone between the PIGS countries and other more stable EU members isn’t what it seems. They hold much of the toxic debt of Greece, Ireland, etc. and look no further than the plunge of over 35% of the Deutche Bank and, the largest bank in Germany (and Europe) since late summer to give credence to the theme that even the strongest economies are exposed to the Euro debt contagion more than we know. And since my last blog, the equivalent of the Pentagon Papers of Wall St was released yet no one cared because the mainstream financial press buried it, and how. This report came from the Fed itself after some 22 months of determined legal posturing to prevent it We now see why, because the details that were released by the Fed concerning the 208 financial crisis were just simply mind- boggling in exposing the truly wicked scope of global banking powerhouses in the 21st century. As telling as it was, it was even more putrid than watching sausage made.
3) US government bonds are yielding a tiny fraction of the true rate of inflation. Why don’t investors demand more than a puny half a percent yield for a two year Treasury bond now priced close to its all-time high? Let’s see if I have this right- the credit source, the US government who just announced an all-time record deficit of over $150 billion for the month of November, can somehow get away with issuing the cheapest debt ever priced in the history of the capital markets? It’s even more bewildering when you consider that US govt debt is being rolled over in ever short maturities and College textbooks in economics of the next generation will just have to label this period with one enormous asterisk. Bond deflation is now hitting full stride that could lead to a mean reversion of the lowest interest rates over the longest period in our history..
So the bottom line on the outlook for economic prosperity and the capital markets is as cloudy as ever despite the substantial levels of debt induced assistance that was held out to be essential to our prosperity. I chuckle at the notion that virtual debt can lift nations to higher prosperity just from the obvious question it poses- if this is so great, why didn’t we just start a $600 billion QE scheme in 1971 when the world allowed us to issue debt without any backing of substance. Why did we wait this long to see the light of such a panacea? Because if you were to believe the Keynesian camp and the monetarist club dogma that a centrally planned and controlled economy in the US was not only possible but essential for our well being and survival you would be forced to ask them why they didn’t enact this brilliant scheme earlier. Do virtuous ideals of balance, moderation, and sustainability, etc. even matter anymore? Such is the delirium to be found at the tail end of a credit cycle now overextended for many years. Yet the cotton is still high and bullish sentiment in equities is peaking right along with the highest levels of debt ever seen on record.
I can recall reading about only one other such period in global finance- the bubble years preceding the meltdown of the South Seas Bubble and the Mississippi Scheme in 1719. In the few short years preceding these bubbles, more paper fiat currency was printed than in all the years of human history to that time. Sound familiar? Remember this fact- since the global credit crisis commenced in the summer of 2007, more total debt and more junk debt has been issued that in any other period in history. Lots of paper was also being issued in the early 18th century, and in these periods illusions of grandeur can be cloaked in plain sight that can incubate some of the vexing conundrums stated above.
This backdrop and other conditions mentioned above allows me to hold that the most prolific stage of this winter cycle is still before us despite near uniform conviction to the contrary by most everyone except the so-called die-hard bears. But I just can’t shake this idea that this is the equivalent of conditions on the eve of the spectacular crash of 1719. Go check out what really happened in 1719 in the search engines under South Seas Bubble and see if you don’t get the same hunch. Prechter’s wave count supports this parallel and so does the Kondratieff theory in that it demands that a great portion of the excesses from the previous credit cycles must be removed before the next true growth cycle can begin anew yet this has not come to pass. So I’m very intrigued at the parallels of these two periods and will be sure to add more content in the coming months to give our readers more isight into comparing these two fascinating periods of global finance. Both periods share some key attributes that make then look more alike to me each day- namely that they are twin tower bookends at the tail end of economic grand super-cycles that each fostered the greatest utility of fiat currency to date in world history.
My gut tells me that an oops! moment is on the horizon. This oops! moment is the realization by the collective consciousness of market participants that debt does matter, for if deficits do matter then all bets are off. Throw out conventional analysis if such a moment were to occur, because the paradigm shift coming from this tipping point would render any assumptions of past cause-effect conditions utterly worthless. I have attached here below today’s blog from my favorite source of Elliott Wave analysis- danerics elliot wave blogspot- and I concur with his market call of a rising yield deflationary collapse on the horizon. It makes perfect sense to me since higher yields are the real weapons of mass destruction- they choke off growth, destroy wealth of anyone owning low yielding debt (nearly every bondholder today), and ultimately trigger default on scores of securities across the spectrum.
Don’t look now, but rates all along the Treasury curve are exploding higher and there’s nothing the Fed can do about it. Given the factual data of all the debt rollovers coming due in the coming 24 months (some $14 trillion in MBS, CRE, leveraged loans, junk bonds, and Treasury debt) it’s likely that market speculators will forward price this once that perception has taken hold. Once this asset inflation express train makes its final stop, the futility of debt induced stimulus as a solution to fending off a Kondratieff Winter will be all too real. So perhaps more intriguing in the coming months than looking at the Dow, the S&P, gold, or even the dollar will be monitoring interest rates Treasury debt to see if yields are rising all all across the curve. Daneric’s blog proposes a radical idea not being discussed much- that the 30 yr Treasury yields will lead all other yields higher and flattening the curve higher. This could serve to ignite a Kondratieff Winter through the trillions in securities betting against such a surprise spike in rates. Yet this debt deflation has already begun as all Treasury yields have spiked higher since QE 2 was announced. That was not supposed to happen if the Fed was buying these bonds, right? Yet yields are rising because Wall St., Congress, and so many have overlooked the deficit thresholds the debt markets could bear. And the irony of President Clinton’s impromptu press conference Friday can’t be overlooked. Here, he was arguing for the extension of Bush tax cuts which would take our deficits into hyper-drive yet it was his savvy and courage in securing the tax increases of late 1993 that settled rates down and provided the stability for the greatest economic and market boom in all of history. Was his speech Friday the bookend of the 1993 event that got the bull market rolling thereafter?
Everyone would agree there is no rising yield deflationary collapse is priced into the markets at present, but should there be? Read the Daneric blog below and see for yourself.
A Tale of Two Cities, Now More Than Ever
In recent weeks the markets have weathered an overdue correction at the end of November and have reached multi-year highs as I surmised in my last post. Yet the Dow Industrials failed to take out the 2010 high made on November 5th, and this divergence may be seen as a bearish indicator for the near term. And the 1250 level on the S&P just ahead is a formidable resistance level I don’t expect to be taken out right away.
It appears that present market levels have forward priced much of the good vibrations out there such as Bush tax cut extensions, 0% interest rates for our lifetime, QE 3,4,5.. etc. and not why may be foreboding. These levels assume that some challenges to sustaining growth just won’t occur. These include assumptions that interest rates can’t rise if the Fed is buying treasuries, deficits just don’t matter, geopolitical risks are intangible, the growing Euro contagion will dissipate, and that commodity inflation won’t materially impact corporate profits or consumer behavior. I doubt the markets will escape the wrath of some of these threats.
Yet global stock markets worldwide forged higher with glaring disparities evident in their relative strength. US market averages get an asterisk from such anemic volume coming in large part from the refusal of the retail investor to take the bait and drink the proverbial cool-aid. Net mutual fund flows for stocks have declined now for 31 consecutive weeks since the May 6th flash crash, and I see that as a compelling “tell” on the state of these markets. It’s clear to most that that the advance from the summer lows has been driven almost completely by a combination of asset managers who have been forced into the rally late to catch up to the benchmark returns (or be fired) and HFT fund flows that have a time span of a conviction to own stocks that can be measured in nanoseconds.. With the Mercury retrograde and the heavy resistance at 1250 upon us, I suspect that maintaining this advance ahead of earnings season will be pretty tough.
So I am bearish near term but still respect the intermediate theme of this reckless asset inflation express train that doesn’t stop for red lights and still has some momentum. But it does face a date of destiny with the gods of the Kondratieff cycle sometime in our near future. In the past, I would have said 1250 is the brick wall that can’t be broken, but my blogs of the past month or two invoke a pattern of further pricing disconnect in the short therm ( one month to one year) that will precede the culmination of the end game so to speak of a deflationary asset bubble occurring thereafter. The human will of reigning central bankers has made a fait accompli decision for all us us through their policy decisions of invoking unlimited application of electronic credit by fiat that has become the law of the land all over the “civilized” world. So what does this mean for all of us? My take is a tale of two cities.
To some, these are the best of times. To most, they are not, and the divergence has never been greater nor the extremes. Perhaps only Dickens could relish and appreciate the modern and confounding world of global finance for what it appears to be- a sobering reflection a two-headed Jannes archetype quite mystifying to most observers.
So why with the pithy quotes and provocative metaphors? I guess it’s comes from the raw and vexing disconnect I see growing each day between the deteriorating reality on the ground and the headlines leading the global markets forward. Hard to say where to begin, but let’s try to parse the core themes of this disconnect playing out before us that color the capital markets so dyslexic to providing meaningful price discovery. Here are some prime examples:
The Euro contagion hits critical mass, yet most market indexes rose recently to multi-year highs on reports that the US would backstop the EU’s ever-expanding bailout of troubled Eurozone countries. But does anyone really believe this plan will have a chance two years after bond vigilantes called Hank Paulsen’s bluff on his threatened “pocket bazooka” that was unmasked as a water pistol? The smart money bid up the credit default swaps of distressed credits knowing, and also salivating, that Paulsen’s proverbial bazooka was just a paper tiger and those vigilantes weren’t about to let Paulsen off the hook with a bluff. So in 2008 credit default swaps of risky credits’s blew out shortly thereafter, and with it the bluff of any potential threat of a proverbial sovereign “bazooka. You would think. The present market seems to have lost sight of Hank Paulsen on his knees before Nancy Pelosi begging for the Congressional fiat decree for the crime of the century in 2008.
But with the recent bailout of Irish banks the EU has taken this bait and now we have déjà vu now on the bazooka bluff. Are investors nuts? Is there anything real in this world? Bernanke confirmed on a Sixty Minutes that further debt monetization beyond the stated $600 billion was possible (likely) methinks he was forgetting that he and Geithner swore before Congress in 2008 that they would never monetize the Treasury debt. Through QE2 they have are subject to inquiries about perjury if anyone in Congress had a spine. But for now let’s just call their statements out for their contradictions to their actions. These actions and policy directives of the EU and the Fed reveal a new breed of riverboat gamblers hell bent on doubling or tripling down on their bets to overcome the structural conflict of their allegiances. Thus through such a rigid dogma they’ve become so hard wired over the years to only one way off the reservation- credit expansion with no table limit and all the markers they need from the American public. But don’t lose sight of who is really the house here- the gambler, not the casino (US citizens). It’s all bad when the gamblers rule the casino or the inmates rule the prisons or the hacks rule the public.
I have put forth the danger of the Fed’s close-minded strategy in the original material put on this site in the late summer of 2007. The core theme at the outset then was that the Fed and other central banks are structurally flawed in that they are hard wired to the Keynesian and monetary schools of thought and aren’t flexible in considering any path of policy directives diametrically opposed to their dogmatic, orthodoxy no matter how things were to play out. What we have now before us perhaps is some version of the nuclear option being played out in front of our very eyes in a slow motion train wreck that most won’t see until its too late. How many gamblers do you know have gotten out of a fix by doubling and tripling down on a bet? History shows that fools and gamblers only learn when they change their mindset and behavior, not the audacity on what they will risk. Of course the Fed and the EU are gambling with the future liabilities of others, not their own money, so it’s quite believable that they could such a colossal risk to overcome what will be seen one day as severely misdirected policy directives by those in power.
2) Now in 2010, some thirty years into a globalization trend that has proven beyond doubt that any notion of “decoupling” between global markets now more connected than ever investors still cling to hopes that the US can be removed from from the mess in the Eurozone even though the EU is our largest trading partner. But take note of this- the prices of credit default swaps on sovereign debt from the leading EU members Germany and France spiked higher last week for the first time in years, indicating the perceived buffer zone between the PIGS countries and other more stable EU members isn’t what it seems. They hold much of the toxic debt of Greece, Ireland, etc. and look no further than the plunge of over 35% of the Deutche Bank and, the largest bank in Germany (and Europe) since late summer to give credence to the theme that even the strongest economies are exposed to the Euro debt contagion more than we know. And since my last blog, the equivalent of the Pentagon Papers of Wall St was released yet no one cared because the mainstream financial press buried it, and how. This report came from the Fed itself after some 22 months of determined legal posturing to prevent it We now see why, because the details that were released by the Fed concerning the 208 financial crisis were just simply mind- boggling in exposing the truly wicked scope of global banking powerhouses in the 21st century. As telling as it was, it was even more putrid than watching sausage made.
3) US government bonds are yielding a tiny fraction of the true rate of inflation. Why don’t investors demand more than a puny half a percent yield for a two year Treasury bond now priced close to its all-time high? Let’s see if I have this right- the credit source, the US government who just announced an all-time record deficit of over $150 billion for the month of November, can somehow get away with issuing the cheapest debt ever priced in the history of the capital markets? It’s even more bewildering when you consider that US govt debt is being rolled over in ever short maturities and College textbooks in economics of the next generation will just have to label this period with one enormous asterisk. Bond deflation is now hitting full stride that could lead to a mean reversion of the lowest debt rates EVER for the longest period EVER thanks mostly to the easy money Fed.
So the bottom line on the outlook for economic prosperity and the capital markets is as cloudy as ever despite the substantial levels of debt induced assistance that was held out to be essential to our prosperity. I chuckle at the notion that virtual debt can lift nations to higher prosperity just from the obvious question it poses- if this is so great, why didn’t we just start a $600 trillion QE scheme in 1971 when the world allowed us to issue debt without any backing of substance. Why did we wait this long to see the light of such a panacea? Because if you were to believe the Keynesian camp and the monetarist club dogma that a centrally planned and controlled economy in the US was not only possible but essential for our well being and survival you would be forced to ask them why they didn’t enact this brilliant scheme earlier. Why have we been forced to accept for so long any sense of limitations when we have been told for so long there are none, none at all? Why have we all been burdened for so long with idealistic themes of virtues of balance, moderation, and sustainability, etc. as if they never really mattered. Is this not just one sad, cruel joke? Such is the delirium to be found perhaps at the tail end of a credit cycle that has overextended its welcome by many, many years. Remember, fools abound everywhere.
I can recall reading about only one other such period in global finance- the bubble years preceding the meltdown of the South Seas Bubble and the Mississippi Scheme in 1719. In the few short years preceding these bubbles, more paper fiat currency was printed than in all the years of human history to that time. Sound familiar? Remember this fact- since the global credit crisis commenced in the summer of 2007, more total debt and more junk debt has been issued that in any other period in history. Lots of paper was also being issued in the early 18th century, and in these periods illusions of grandeur can be cloaked in plain sight that can incubate some of the vexing conundrums stated above.
This backdrop and other conditions mentioned above allows me to hold that the most prolific stage of this winter cycle is still before us despite near uniform conviction t the contrary by nearly everyone except the so-called die-hard bears. But I just can’t shake this idea that we may now be living in the equivalent of 1719. Go check out what really happened in 1719 in the search engines under South Seas Bubble and see if you don’t get the same hunch. Prechter’s wave count supports this parallel and so does the Kondratieff theory in that it demands that a great portion of the excesses from the previous credit cycles must be removed before the next true growth cycle can begin anew yet this has not come to pass at present. So I’m very intrigued at the parallels of these two periods and will be sure to add more content in the coming months to give our readers more insight into comparing these two fascinating periods of global finance. They look more alike to me each day.
Yield Creep all along the Treasury Curve, courtesy of the Bond Vigilantes
The tattletale signs of a macho agenda gone wrong were evident the past few days in several key measures in the capital markets. QE 2 was hailed as a pancea, a manna from heaven, a win-win for the markets that would rise no matter if the economy was recovering or not. But the reversal of fortunes evident the past few sessions begs to differ. After all, who outside of any proponent of wave theory would have expected a meaningful rally in the US dollar and a rout in gold, silver and Treasuries all along the curve, even the short end? Or that the S&P is now 2% lower than its level in April? It just supports our theme that the Fed is no more in control of our economy than the Wizard of Oz. But behind that curtain of theirs, they do have some impact- just the wrong kind.
Global central bankers have usurped sufficient power to give them unfettered seigniorage over nations. Their policies assure that we all pay higher prices for the basic things we need each day and help to prop up most paper assets above their true market clearing levels. Interestingly though, since QE 2 was announced gold is down $80, the dollar is up 2% and interest rates all along the curve are much higher. The Fed really doesn’t control much other than forcing inflation upon consumers and now many businesses now seeing their margins squeezed from ever higher input prices. There is no free lunch this QE 2 and yet much to reckon with in the fallout of unwinding several trillion in toxic paper in the coming years.
Now that the financial piñata of QE2 has been proclaimed the law of the land with hardly any blowback, we will see if it fares better than the monetization plan that has failed so miserably in Japan over the past 20 years. Will it be sufficient to overcome fourth Kondratieff Winter, now packing some $40 trillion in private debt and $15 trillion of US government debt? And so much of it is coming due very soon. And as we have reported for some time, our Treasury debt has continued to roll over in recent years in shorter maturities as fewer dare to invest far out on the curve. In fact, since QE2 was put in play in early November, interest rates all along the curve have spike much higher. Many expected the long end to suffer, but to the chagrin of the Fed shorter maturities have spiked much higher too. This can mean only one thing- the bond vigilantes are back, and that’s not good. This makes more difficult any efforts in the future to refinance our debt at record low yields. Well, we knew these puny yields couldn’t last forever but going forward the interest we must pay on the debt could rise exponentially and is sure to be a greater component of our budget in the years to come.
In my last post when QE2 was announced I stated a belief QE2 had delayed any potential economic winter by several months but that does not preclude the chance there may be a series of very sharp corrections in the interim. In the past week the market has lost over 2% in a much needed correction and there is a chance even we could witness another flash crash if the European PIGS contagion can’t be contained. But the asset inflation express is still in play for now and there is no doubt to me the Fed would actually buy S&P futures instead of Treasury bonds if the market were to drop too much. Therefore I would go long stocks after any flash crash in the near term so long as the S&P didn’t close below its upwardly sloping channel line (around 1080 now) that held several times over the summer when it appeared economic output was heading for the dreaded double-dip.
The global de-leveraging process is just in the early innings and still so much toxic debt remaining that needs to be written down. A tipping point could manifest sometime next year if some major structural changes are not enforced soon. But unless a significant shock occurs in the near term, I still expect the inflation express train to resume soon for a bit longer before giving way to meaningful austerity in western economies sorely in need of deleveraging. The geo-cosmic signatures now prevailing are noted by two predominant traits- grand scale (Jupiter) and recklessness (Mars). That’s why we are in for one heck of rumble here in the months and years ahead.
I refer back to the comments posted here on October 3rd that framed this period as heavyweight prize fight taking place between the Federal Reserve and a looming Kondratieff winter. Give Ben the first two rounds but I suspect a KW counter-punch is coming pretty soon. But the knockout is sure to come later either by the deflationary debt defaults of the K-Winter or through the combination of technological advances and the financial alchemy of the ingenious and crafty Ben Bernanke. But as this title fight moves to the middle and late rounds let’s remember that mitigating the worst of this winter is entirely possible if sufficient reforms are taken (i.e. willful debt reduction, austerity, etc). But lest we forget that no past Kondratieff cycle has ever ended without the removal of the excesses built up over the previous credit cycle. Given the prohibitive levels of debt and recklessness seen in the past 25 years of the present Kondratieff cycle, the rehabilitation from such an epic wave of debt induced growth is sure to be daunting if the political will remains oblivious to the realities underpinning the nature of the Kondratieff cycle.
Kicking the Kondratieff can down the road – again
Two elections happened last week but only one really mattered. The mid-term elections gave Republican control in the House but that alone doesn’t guarantee real change. The election held by the FOMC the next day does. It means higher prices for the goods and services needed by all Americans and it also means that stock and asset speculation will continue unabated. You can decide for yourselves if this form of change, one very real and tangibly defined, is really beneficial for our nation’s long term welfare. It probably depends on who you ask and I would suspect the results to be even more polarized than the entrenched red state/blue state map in national politics.
The Fed’s decision to further monetize Treasury debt by $600 billion over a few months was amplified with language in the policy statement smacking of arrogance and conviction. Throw in speculation over a potential QE 3 and 4 and you have a green light for stocks and inflation to break out higher soon.
And last week global stock markets surged higher and in fact broke through key technical resistance to suggest a new leg of the rally had begun. And for the first time since the summer of 2008, even I believe equities will rise in the near term, but not in the context of a new bull market. I believe we are about to witness the final push higher in the P2 countertrend rally that began in early March 2009. Below I will outline a case supporting higher prices in the near term and why QE 2,3,4 etc. may only delay the coming winter.
I had expected that by the late summer of 2010 that the US stock market would have broken through their key support levels on the channel line. A few times this year (Feb 8th, July 2, and in late August) the US markets were really on the ropes, clinging to fragile support. Yet each time the S&P index approached the key level of support on the upwardly sloping channel line drawn from the March 2009 lows, the markets bounced off those critical levels that could not be breached. And with this occurring three times in a matter of a few months, the resilience at the critical support line had been proven. So after the third stick save in late August, the few market players left (HFT’s and large institutions primarily) knew it was safe to take the plunge back into equities. And since that past bounce September 1 the markets have surged almost 20% higher in large part to the “Bernanke Put” implied in his late August speech at Jackson Hole suggesting more QE on the way. Despite the weaker economic growth at the time, the markets began their Pay it Forward march higher. The spike we saw last week had all the hallmarks of a relief rally manifesting by virtue that the Holy Trinity of Wall Street wishes had been granted- Megaton QE from Ben, Republican control of the House, and the Obama olive branch on extending the Bush tax cuts.
It’s very tempting for those short the market now to feel more hardened by the impression that the Fed has shot its wad and that nearly all the forces supporting the market have been fully appreciated at these levels. Before the events last week, I was in that camp, and although I still maintain the K-Winter is likely to have a second coming from the 2008 event, I must say to our readers I am convinced it’s not happening anytime soon. First, the technical read suggest a follow-through higher based on the fact that Friday the S&P broke through the April 26 high of 1220, albeit by one point. But with all three indexes now making new 2010 highs and with the Dow Theory confirmed for now with the Dow Transports also making new highs, it’s hard to argue a new uptrend has not been established. We are dealing with one determined bunch these days- the Fed and the mythical Plunge Protection Team determined to goose the markets. It would be a conspiracy thriller if weren’t so transparently obvious.
Further supporting this is the notion that bond investors are getting the memo that the coming years are sure to be the most inflationary since the 1970’s and thus stocks are sure to benefit from increased flows due to asset reallocation from bonds to stocks. This could provide a missing component from the current rally- the retail investor. After all, who wants to be left out of such a great party? I think the policy statement from the Fed this week puts the proverbial fork in the great bond rally from 1981. It’s toast.
But to me perhaps the most compelling reason I found to support that this winter was pushed out a bit was the recent weekly comments from financial astrologer Ray Merriman at www.mmacycles.com. I have grown ever more fond of his work for one simple reason- his forecasts over the 8-9 months I have followed him have proven not only to be the most accurate, but also the most nimble in these extraordinary times. He’s been able to thread the needle in a very tough environment to forecast. I have come to appreciate this component of financial forecasting more than ever in 2010 and wish I had subscribed to his service sooner. His comments on November 5th were intriguing, insightful and colorful. His forecast indicates that the astrological forces influencing equities now term suggest prices to continue to rise.
He cites two conjunctions that will continue to exert a prevailing influence on stocks, and for that matter most asset classes except bonds. First, he cites the Jupiter and Uranus conjunction he calls the “Get Out of My Way Asset Inflation Express” because of its no holds barred aspects. Together with the “I Don’t Stop For Red Lights” nature of the Mars in Sagitarius conjunction, the prevailing astrological forces at present suggest a theme that could be best regarded as “Damn the Torpedoes, full-steam ahead!”
Some out there call this approach “Don’t fight the Fed”, but I don’t believe in that one-size-fits-all moniker. One of the most recent pieces found on the EW site proves that such a mantra was futile in 2008 when the Fed was promising a new program each day to battle old man K Winter and each one proved futile in keeping stocks from plunging. That’s why I have come to believe that the most influential factors that impact the capital markets are born from the forces exerted from the cosmos and what Dr. Carl Calleman refers to as the Cosmic Tree of Life (see Mayan Section for more). The track record of these influences on market direction is formidable when compared to simple slogan’s like “Don’t fight the Fed”. They imply that while this at times may be true, the higher truth is that there could be something else entirely steering this ship. I suspect that this may be the case now and could explain why the markets are rising in spite of an ever growing debt bubble that becomes more problematic with each wink and nod that comes after every new round of QE by the central bankers of the world. We know full well much of the rally isn’t from through traditional price discovery, but who cares when we’re having so much fun, right?
Whether this rally can be sustained to render the gains from March 2009 as a bull market instead of a well extended bear market counter trend rally may depend upon if and how well the US government and our people will choose to make the difficult changes needed to restore our prosperity. Much of the western world suffering from the fool’s game of leverage have come to their senses and are in the early to mid stages of painful austerity programs sure to stabilize their floundering ships. But the US seems hard wired by nature to embrace deficit spending and we are way behind the curve here. A profound change in our attitude must occur soon, and perhaps it has roots with the election of so many Tea Party candidates who promised to reign in the runaway deficits. Even though there is little evidence to date in past mid-terms that these “so-called” real changes are soon forthcoming (an end to partisan bickering, runaway spending, etc.) there is a brief window for change now that a bunch of determined upstarts have made their way to Congress. Perhaps their energy and the recent stability evident in our economy will enable us to act now to alleviate any possible second act of the K-Winter. We established in the Jubilee icon of the K-Wave section that so long as we embraced the principles of this divine cycle we could prevent any economic winter, and we still can if we are so inclined.
Big Ben to K-Winter: Let’s get READY TO RUMMMMMMBLE!
The message from the Fed’s last policy statement set the stage for the most
sensational prizefight of our time, and the stakes are higher than we know.
In one corner, it’s the reigning champ- Ben Bernanke, the unflappable czar
reigning over the global monetary monarchy. Nickname: “Helicopter Ben”.
Recent accolades: Time Man of the Year 2009. In the other corner- his arch
enemy, the one he refuses to call by name- the Kondratieff Winter. KW has
no nickname, and while his accolades are more formidable they are too far
removed for anyone alive to remember (this by design, of course). Both are
determined and in peak form but only one can prevail and it is sure to be by
knockout. Both share just one thing-their date with destiny has now arrived.
So why all the build-up? Because the proverbial gauntlet was thrown down
by Ben and the Fed at their last meeting. They left no doubt they stand ready
to unleash monetary nuclear warfare at the slightest hint of slowing growth.
But there’s another big reason the Fed is wielding their QE bazooka again-
they know full well the threat that K-Winter’s deflationary forces are reaching
a critical mass that could jeopardize such a fragile recovery. In one part of
the policy statement, he alluded to the threat of certain conditions that are
by axiom deflationary without calling them so, instead choosing to carefully
parse that section of the statement.
This underscores the true enigma of any deflationary Kondratieff Winter-
those like Bernanke who understand it deny its threat through a conviction it
can be overcome by brute force while the general public remains oblivious to
its very existence. And why not? Nothing about the Kondratieff Wave is ever
discussed by the mainstream financial press, so the public remains ignorant
about the significance of long-wave credit cycles until it’s too late. But you
can be darn sure the Fed is quite attuned to its potent force and likely why
they refuse to address it or acknowledge it. And why should they? No one in
the financial press has taken them to task on it.
So here’s the rub- the investing public believes the Fed is taking all of these
draconian measures to spur growth yet we all know the limitations of Fed
policy to induce credit expansion. It’s just not happening folks. They know
this but choose the radical QE route because they are for the short term
more concerned about maintaining asset price stability, even at levels far
above the equilibrium clearing price. Why? Because although they are quite
aware of the implications underlying the K-Wave theory, they are still sure
they can defeat mother nature through extending credit ad infinitum to the
point where the next cycle of economic growth can overcome the potential
detriment inherent with debt levels so high. But the arithmetic is just not on
their side because at present the excesses to be removed from the system
are just too prohibitive.
It seems a tipping point is soon at hand that will allow investors to see
what Prechter and the Austrian school have advocated- you can’t overcome
a deflationary asset bubble with a credit-cased system. Credit has its
limitations, it is not the magic elixir the Fed would have you believe. The
sooner investors can see this for themselves the better or else they will
encounter first hand the perils of their own “Minsky Moment”. (I have added
a small piece on this below). In the meantime however, we are in the twilight
of the Fed’s influence and I expect the period from now until their demise will
seem like the Twilight Zone to us.
In my last blog on the eve of the fateful Fed meeting in September, I mused
that the results of that election (a handful of Fed governors and Bernanke)
may possibly impact the average US citizen more than the elections in early
November. What transpired after the Fed’s “election day” was a mad, insane
rush from all major central banks around the worlds to race to devalue their
own currency. This election produced real results (bad) right away versus
the November elections which aren’t likely produce anything meaningful in
the short term due to more Congressional gridlock. That’s a far cry from the
manic and surreal developments resulting from this “election” which has
set the stage for so many dubious new all-time records to fall. Gold makes
new all-time highs every new day and Treasury bonds keep setting record
low yields, record high prices, and record bid to cover ratios at each of the
Treasury auctions this week. Ho hum, just another boring week of parabolic
extremes in the capital markets. The Fed’s “election” DID matter.
And we can expect more of the same in the coming weeks and months. In
fact, I am bracing for a “high-noon” melodrama that will redefine surreal.
Why? Because Big Ben knows that the first round of QE together will all
the fiscal bailouts have proven insufficient to restore growth and he must
send the strongest message possible to the markets that he will stop at
nothing to defeat deflation, even if he really can’t. Oh but try he will. Just
before the last Fed meeting, financial astrologer Ray Merriman was sure he
would step on the gas given that his natal astrology make-up indicated he
was inclined to do so. Never mind the calm and cool persona, Bernanke is
the “all-in” warrior with no apologies. Give him his due, he is no phony. This
combat is what he signed up for, so don’t expect he won’t err on the side
of being too aggressive. Knowing this, and also knowing full well the power
and might of this huge deflationary debt bubble, we can expect an epic
prizefight to unfold in the near term. Buckle up my friends for a very wild
ride.
The first round goes to Big Ben. In September stocks went up about 10%in
large part because the Fed jammed tens of billions of US Treasuries down
the throats of their primary dealers to induce them to speculate across the
spectrum, sending the Netflixes and Pricelines of the world soaring into the
stratosphere much like Ariba in the spring of 2000. Such parabolic moves
usually precede a top and a nasty reversal. How may this play out? My belief
is through a short squeeze on the US Dollar given the present groupthink
at 95% bears on the USD. I do expect the final and decisive rounds of this
prizefight to go old man K-Winter. Many of the tell-tale events and conditions
that occur at market tops that were mentioned before on this site have now
come to pass in recent weeks and months to set the stage for the final act
(P3).
Some of these are:
Exhibit A: Checklist of Conditions Marking a Secular Top:
The world’s largest IPO just closed (Petrobras, just weeks after China AG)
The US govt would claim victory over the bailout decisions re Citi, AIG and
GM through pawing these toxic credits back to the US public. The US has
been dumping toxic billions of shares of Citi in the public market for months,
the GM IPO is weeks away, and AIG hints at getting Uncle Sam off it’s back
with the plan announced Friday. Yet in each of these cases, we taxpayers
are still stuck with tens of billions in write-downs of each.
Tallest building in the world opens same year- Dubai 2010 (Think Empire
State 1931)
Trade War Rhetoric at fever pitch (think Smoot Hawley 1931)
Wall St Movie released reflecting our obsession with material wishes even
while our markets crash around the same time (1987). Don’t laugh- this one is
all about bubbles and clearly suggests the biggest one is yet to come.
Insanity rule prevails- fix old problems with same thing that created original
problem- more debt and credit to fix a crisis caused by the same thing.
Parabolic moves in Netflix and PCLN ala Ariba, Pets.com etc. in 2000
Obama declares a Depression was averted, govt declares end of recession
Investors show insatiable demand for junk paper in mad dash for high-yield
Four flash-crashes alone in the past week in individual stocks (Nucor, etc)
Recently reported massive imbalance of insider selling to insider buying
I could go on and on, but what’s the point. The market momentum is likely to
soon run its course and leave a vacuum of buyers behind. The current period
marking cognitive dissonance is sure to be replaced by a herd averse to this
madness. Mutual fund outflows decreased for the 21stconsecutive week and
yet we are at multi-month highs. So look out soon for a catalyst that could
trigger another mass sell decision by investors tired of playing this game.
Never Mind November 2nd- the Election Day that Matters is September 21, 2010
The fuss over the November elections is now approaching a full fever pitch, yet there’s another election this fall that may prove to be more crucial. It will be made in two days by an electorate of less than a dozen of our citizens yet it could possibly impact the lives of most Americans more directly than the outcome of the November mid-term elections. This election has been announced yet has no advertising, campaign slogan, or rallies. This election occurs on a regular basis about 9 times each year, usually without tremendous fanfare. But not the one Tuesday.
At 2:15 EST September 21, 2010 the Fed will release its policy statement and we will know then if they intend to ramp up QE 2.0 or pull back. At their last meeting August 9th, the language was particularly disturbing and caught the markets off guard and for three weeks the market slid on fears the recovery had stalled. But Since the beginning of September, the risk trade was turned
on again in large part to the Fed’s frequent injections of liquidity in the markets through their Permanent Open Market Operations program (POMO) further goosing the markets. But if the recovery is so stable, why the need for such a draconian approach as monetizing our own debt? Such a policy shamelessly sanctions a Ponzi scheme that hides in plain sight, one that dares you to call them out on it. I do feel Helicopter Ben is bold enough to throw the printing presses into overdrive, I feel there is now too much dissention within the Fed to allow him to pull such a dangerous lever, especially this close to the November elections. After all, the Fed is supposed to at least appear neutral to political pressure. The end game of QE gone mad is probably set for 2011 when the fallout of the bursting of the deflationary asset bubble is at its fever pitch. Then he will have all the cover he needs to awaken the Frankenstein of hyper-inflationary measures.
But of course, Ben could throw down the gauntlet Tuesday and opt for more QE under the cover of perceived low inflation and the recent approval of Basle III which allows banks up to 8 years to get their capital ratios in order (what a farce). If he dares to do this, the markets could well break out and rally to 1150 or a bit higher before the damage incurred to interest rates and
commodity inflation threaten the recovery. This would represent a blow-off top much like the NASDAQ in March of 200 or gold in the final days of 1979. This would be an exhaustive climax rally that would have sucked in as many bulls as possible and cause most of the shorts to cover. Then sentiment would peak as nearly everyone would believe that a new bull market had really arrived.
Such a scenario would be the ideal set-up for the dreaded Primary Wave three to take hold and trigger a “mass sell decision” point that would cause the S&P to break support and fall below 1000. Gold and silver would follow suit, rallying with stocks then reversing together. The dollar would first plunge on news of QE but then rally once the risk trade was removed. So the US dollar is really the key here because the Kondratieff Winter scenario and Elliott Wave models both are based on a theme of deflation coming from a contraction of credit through an acceleration in debt defaults across the spectrum. For this to take shape, the dollar, measured by the US Dollar Index
must hold support at around the 80 level (it’s at 81.30 tonight). A severe break under this level would suggest that inflationary forces would prevail in the short term, and in that scenario stocks would rise despite the tens of trillions of debt compounding all over the world. So therefore I am watching the US Dollar index with heightened scrutiny in the short term for signs of the direction of the pivot that is implied within the present technical and fundamental backdrop.
Or the Fed may signal an end to the QE ramp through the cover that there was ample evidence to support that the economy had stabilized enough since the last meeting to render liquidity injections each week as unwarranted. If this is the case, look for the markets to sell off hard and fast Tuesday because expectations of QE are already priced into the market. This week marks also
some very intriguing and powerful geo-cosmic signatures that suggest severe reversals are very possible. For more on this I urge our readers to each week read the upcoming weekly comments from Ray Merriman at www.mmacycles.com. Without a doubt, we are in for a rollercoaster ride this week that may impact the market’s direction for some time to come. Events could signal a pivot from deflation to inflation as the primary driver of market forces if QE is extended or they could also trigger the mass sell decision point referred to above. Below I have added some new material supporting why I feel although there may be a false break-out this week, the most likely outcome is a powerful sell-off featuring the hallmarks of a K- Winter- debt, default and deflation.
A multitude of signs now suggest major market reversals soon in the US markets and this is well supported by the abundance of content on our site relating to the K-Wave, the Elliott Wave, the impact of the present reigning astrology ,etc. But today I wish to introduce another key metric suggesting a Kondratieff Winter is looming- the FX markets.
The fx markets indicate a major structural shift in place that will shatter the so-called “risk trade” to pieces. Meaningful trend shifts in the fx markets have been in place throughout much of 2010 that haven’t gotten a morsel of attention from the mainstream financial press. But today we have added two links to help or readers sort out what’s coming from these developments.
One is www.fxsteeet.com, a site with comprehensive content on the currency markets that has recently featured our material on their site for educational purposes. The other is www.the yenguy.wordpress.com, a financial blog I feel is among these best I have ever seen in framing the “big picture” linking the global currency, debt, and equity markets. Their analysis makes sense of these complex and dynamic markets through a too that doesn’t lend itself to
manipulation- the carry trade.
Until I sorted through this material I never imagined how any tool could frame the prevailing condition so concisely and without fanfare. He integrates the nuances of the various carry trade currency pairs (AUD/JPY, EUR/JPY, etc) within the framework of the Elliott Wave and K-Wave paradigm. We all know that everywhere asset allocation is influenced by these carry trade pairs yet the mainstream financial press rarely addresses these crucial relationships that define the ebb and flow of risk capital throughout the global markets. I have attached below the comments of the blog as they relate to the onset of the Kondratieff Winter below. Here’s a recap of the key dates in 2010 when changes in the carry trade preceded turns in the markets:
April 10, 2010- K- Winter Debt deflation arrives to the US stock market- the peak is in
The fx markets pivoted dramatically and determined the Euro had peaked. Fx markets sniffed out the trouble brewing with the European sovereign debt crisis before the equity or debt markets. The US market continued to rise for the next two weeks, peaking on April 26 before the realization had set in that a global sovereign debt crisis had arrived. The US market peaked on that date and is now still down over 5% from those highs despite the recent rally. The yen begins a spectacular rally that will see it make all-time highs vs the Euro and multi-decade highs vs. the US Dollar.
August 11, 2010- The yield curve flattens after Bernancke’s policy statement
Investors in government bonds of all maturities scream foul at the Fed’s policy statement indicating a policy reversal opting for more quantitative easing. This fateful decision caught the markets off guard in that they wondered out loud if the Fed was aware of something (negative) the market’s weren’t. The US stock market sold off hard for three weeks and for the first time since the financial crisis began Treasury bond yield moved higher during a period of undeniable erosion in economic activity. The considerable flattening of the yield curve can mean that investors have begun to distrust sovereign debt, even from the US.
September 1, 2010- K-Winter debt deflation arrives to the US Treasury market- the peak is in
Bonds (TLT) peak as debt deflation comes to the bond market. Currency trends explode that aren’t so subtle. The Euro makes all-time lows against the Swiss France and the AUD/JPY carry trade implodes and the yen soars to new heights against most major currencies. What is this in fx telling us? That there is now a bi-polar global currency dynamic now emerging, and it calls
for investors to know what end is up in fx because these trends have preceded larger moves in the stock and bond markets.
So then, when will this tipping point finally come to pass? Certainly there are many who are support the K-Winter theme that may be a bit frustrated it has yet to arrive in full force, but news on the ground indicates it won’t be long. This beast is being battled by the forces seeking to maintain the status quo (Washington, Wall St, Federal Reserve, ECB, etc.). But their efforts are now suffering from the law of diminishing returns because their objectives are not being met despite the most desperate attempts imaginable. This is the real game-changer because this truth is now slowly but surely becoming embedded into our collective psyche. We are now seeing for ourselves just how impotent that wizard behind the curtain really is. All of the content above, especially the Elliott Wave technical read, suggests that the markets are likely to encounter another serious inflection point that may trigger the “tipping point “ condition Robert Prechter has forecasted that will be unlike any other in history. This condition would be the rarest of breeds in that most investors along the spectrum would for once all agree there was no reason to own stocks.
Ironically, this is unlikely to occur until there is first widespread optimism for stocks by a great number of investors, as is the case today. Yet that wasn’t the case in mid-August or late June when the markets came so close to breaking key technical support levels. So how were the bulls able to hold their ground each time over the summer? Well they certainly benefited from the extremely low volume that proved t be far lower than typical summer months. So it wasn’t too hard for those forces to hold at those key technical levels so long as the economic news was just awful but not horrific. For the time being it has been just simply awful but not so horrific for capitulation. It will be interesting to see how the ever deflating economic news is greeted by a market that is finally back in full force in the coming weeks.
More evidence points to a period in the coming weeks for a violent reversal in the capital markets. The obvious parallel is 2008. In mid July 2008, oil traded at a ridiculous all-time high of $147 but was soon smacked down hard, very hard. A commodity bubble was in place that fooled the stock market. I have attached here for our readers the stock charts of 2008 and I suspect few will recall that the S&P rallied nearly 1000 points in the days preceding the crash in September 2009. At that point the housing bubble had already been exposed to be a massive fraud and yet the markets were near their all-time highs. The banks had also recently passed the so- called “stress tests”. Of course, only weeks later the real stress tests to be measured were on the masses of investors who trusted their leaders, regulators, and the system itself. In Europe it seems they have taken leave of their senses, for they have fallen for the same trap. Stress tests in the spring, crash in the fall only weeks later. What a farce! The swings in the market from August through September 2008 showcase that our stock market does not reflect the reality behind the scenes one bit.

The Overrated Double-Dip- Much Ado About the Wrong Thing
The whipsaw that has marked the summer of 2010 continued in full force last week. The 5% decline in August was met with a sharp rally mid-week once September began as investors viewed the ISM and Employment reports as evidence of no double-dip. In fact, all summer it seems everyone has become
so enamored about the prospects of this double-dip it seems to me we have lost sight of a much larger threat to our capital markets-a meltdown in the debt markets triggered by defaults of sovereign and municipal defaults. These are not only likely but inevitable, yet the markets now levitate as if they are neither- and that’s the great disconnect right there. Today our markets assume that Illinois and Greece won’t default, yet they will. And of course this will change everything very quickly.
Those who know the K-Wave theory know the excesses hiding in plain sight will be purged sooner or later. They know that bond yields will rise even if investors know economic growth will be meager or even negative. The flight to “quality” myth of US Treasuries is sure to be exposed soon as the bond vigilantes emerge from hiding. In fact, I would suspect we saw the all-time peak in Treasuries recently because yields reversed much higher last week, especially on the long end of the curve. Is this trend were to continue it would have enormous ramifications upon all the capital markets because so many large and leveraged bets would have to be reversed. We must remember that these govt Treasury bond markets are so much larger than the stock market that if something unexpected occurred across the spectrum it could profoundly impact global financial markets through their exposure to financial derivatives contracts which are extremely susceptible to sudden moves in interest rates, even small ones. This is the real canary in the coal mine that I suspect will catch everyone off guard. There may or may not be a Treasury “bubble” today, yet there surely will be one tomorrow.
Another such canary is the US dollar. Although it remains the whipping boy for monetarism gone amok, it will remain the strongest fiat currency in the short term because as most counter-party contracts in the world are dollar denominated and thus cannot be so easily reversed, even if the US maintains huge deficits. The sheer practicality of unwinding US Dollar contracts is too daunting to render the USD as anything but the strongest fiat currency in the world for the foreseeable future, yet so many have bet on the other side of that trade. This squares nicely with the notion above regarding the perceived “sanctity” of US Treasury bonds and notes. The poof of this will be seen when US Treasuries sell off on bad news Don’t look now, but this just happened last week when US treasuries reversed lower last week during a period of deteriorating economic news.
If either of the above conditions take hold to any extent, then any discussion of PE multiples, cash on corporate balance sheets, merger prospects, and the like will just be idle conversation, relegated to those who choose to insist that classic fundamental analysis actually matters. It usually does matter except in those extraordinary times when the effects of economic global super-cycles are just too daunting to ignore. We now live in those times, for better or for worse, and their implications I feel trump the standard framework upon which we have come to value or markets. Do deficits matter? Very soon we will see, once and for all. It seems sure some form of the Bush tax cuts will be extended and other forms of QE by the Fed and stimulus from Washington are also forthcoming. I suspect that instead of helping us all as advertised that instead the measures give the bond vigilantes all the cover they need to dump Treasuries and upset the applecart that has allowed the Keynesian economics to become the monster that has roamed the countryside for so long. And that would be good for us all.
